wait-discipline: no retry/resume protocol for transient API errors or quota stalls #46

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Safe (bounded, escalates) but deviates from the SREQ quota path exactly on the F-PO-46-3-1 seam: the two-test decomposition dropped cause-specific rescheduling from the keep-the-incident path. Fix is localized: when the re-aimed/next cause is resumable-quota, attempt sup_parse_reset before falling back to backoff. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Safe (bounded, escalates) but deviates from the SREQ quota path exactly on the F-PO-46-3-1 seam: the two-test decomposition dropped cause-specific rescheduling from the keep-the-incident path. Fix is localized: when the re-aimed/next cause is resumable-quota, attempt sup_parse_reset before falling back to backoff. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Operator-typo surface on every helper; the intended usage error never fires. Trivial fix: `shift 2 2>/dev/null || { usage; exit $SUP_EXIT_USAGE; }` or validate ${2+set} before shifting. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Operator-typo surface on every helper; the intended usage error never fires. Trivial fix: `shift 2 2>/dev/null || { usage; exit $SUP_EXIT_USAGE; }` or validate ${2+set} before shifting. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "No code-execution path (the value never reaches command position), but it is exactly the unquoted-expansion-of-untrusted-data class, flagged independently by the Bug Hunter and Static Security. Fix: newline-delimited ALERTED with quoted while-read (or printf '%s' \"$ALERTED\"), no bare-word step. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "No code-execution path (the value never reaches command position), but it is exactly the unquoted-expansion-of-untrusted-data class, flagged independently by the Bug Hunter and Static Security. Fix: newline-delimited ALERTED with quoted while-read (or printf '%s' \"$ALERTED\"), no bare-word step. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Documentation defect with real cross-project misfire potential; trivial placeholder substitution. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Documentation defect with real cross-project misfire potential; trivial placeholder substitution. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Degenerate declared bound, but 'bound 0 = never resume' is unambiguous operator intent. Fix: check INC_ATTEMPT >= SUP_RETRY_BOUND immediately before firing as well. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Degenerate declared bound, but 'bound 0 = never resume' is unambiguous operator intent. Fix: check INC_ATTEMPT >= SUP_RETRY_BOUND immediately before firing as well. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Transcript activity that produced the stall is positive evidence the old incident ended; closing the incident there matches F-PO-46-3-1 half (a). Fix sits in the same dispatch block as CR-1's fix. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Transcript activity that produced the stall is positive evidence the old incident ended; closing the incident there matches F-PO-46-3-1 half (a). Fix sits in the same dispatch block as CR-1's fix. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "No execution or exfiltration path found; impact is a shifted schedule, still bounded. Fix: require a leading alpha character (reject '/' prefix) and cross-check the zone round-trips (e.g. TZ=zone date +%Z differs from the literal for known zones is not reliable — minimally reject leading '/' and keep fail-closed on parse doubt). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "No execution or exfiltration path found; impact is a shifted schedule, still bounded. Fix: require a leading alpha character (reject '/' prefix) and cross-check the zone round-trips (e.g. TZ=zone date +%Z differs from the literal for known zones is not reliable — minimally reject leading '/' and keep fail-closed on parse doubt). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Reachable only via hand-edited or version-skewed state.json, but the degradation is misleading rather than loud. Fix: `// defaults` in each jq read plus a sanity check that refuses to start on non-numeric tunables. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Reachable only via hand-edited or version-skewed state.json, but the degradation is misleading rather than loud. Fix: `// defaults` in each jq read plus a sanity check that refuses to start on non-numeric tunables. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Stale user-facing message introduced by this feature's edit. Trivial: say 15, or drop the number so the next widening cannot re-stale it. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Stale user-facing message introduced by this feature's edit. Trivial: say 15, or drop the number so the next widening cannot re-stale it. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Not exploitable under typical umasks; cheap to close with `umask 077` before the mkdir (subshell or save/restore). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Not exploitable under typical umasks; cheap to close with `umask 077` before the mkdir (subshell or save/restore). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Input-validation gap at the entry seam; trivial to normalize (strip leading zeros / reject) and to copy attach's check into detach. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Input-validation gap at the entry seam; trivial to normalize (strip leading zeros / reject) and to copy attach's check into detach. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Operator/harness-supplied (session ids are UUIDs), so not hostile in practice, but a quoting slip currently produces silent wrong-session supervision instead of a loud refusal. Trivial: validate sid against [A-Za-z0-9-]+. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Operator/harness-supplied (session ids are UUIDs), so not hostile in practice, but a quoting slip currently produces silent wrong-session supervision instead of a loud refusal. Trivial: validate sid against [A-Za-z0-9-]+. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Currently inconsequential — the classifier's in-progress branch keys only on provenance-backed discriminators (assistant role, stop_reason, isApiErrorMessage) — but it is exactly the drift risk the provenance convention exists to catch. Fix: capture a real in-progress record from a live transcript on this box into the sample + provenance files and rebuild the fixture from it. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Currently inconsequential — the classifier's in-progress branch keys only on provenance-backed discriminators (assistant role, stop_reason, isApiErrorMessage) — but it is exactly the drift risk the provenance convention exists to catch. Fix: capture a real in-progress record from a live transcript on this box into the sample + provenance files and rebuild the fixture from it. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Test-infra portability; the guard's own comment promises the skip. Fix: probe touch's relative -d form (or pin mtime via `touch -d @epoch`, which the local-fs probe pattern already models). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Test-infra portability; the guard's own comment promises the skip. Fix: probe touch's relative -d form (or pin mtime via `touch -d @epoch`, which the local-fs probe pattern already models). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Tests pass because neither classifier nor parser keys on the separator, but a future change that does would be green-lit against wrong bytes. Trivial: use $'\\xc2\\xb7' or printf. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Tests pass because neither classifier nor parser keys on the separator, but a future change that does would be green-lit against wrong bytes. Trivial: use $'\\xc2\\xb7' or printf. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Same class as the AC-9a race already fixed on this branch. Fix: give the first attach a long backoff (the test owns the fixture CLAUDE.md and can rewrite tunables between attaches) so it cannot fire pre-kill, then a short-backoff reclaim attach. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Same class as the AC-9a race already fixed on this branch. Fix: give the first attach a long backoff (the test owns the fixture CLAUDE.md and can rewrite tunables between attaches) so it cannot fire pre-kill, then a short-backoff reclaim attach. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Operator-facing misinformation in exactly the states where trust matters. Fix: branch on state.status — resume-in-flight explains the stale heartbeat; status 'starting' explains a null pid. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Operator-facing misinformation in exactly the states where trust matters. Fix: branch on state.status — resume-in-flight explains the stale heartbeat; status 'starting' explains a null pid. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Hygiene while the file is already under edit; delete it. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Hygiene while the file is already under edit; delete it. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Rare (requires the tail to move between every schedule and fire) and each abort is individually informative, but unbounded record spam is a real forge-hygiene risk. A dedup/bound for aborts fits naturally beside CR-1's tail-signal fix. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Rare (requires the tail to move between every schedule and fire) and each abort is individually informative, but unbounded record spam is a real forge-hygiene risk. A dedup/bound for aborts fits naturally beside CR-1's tail-signal fix. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the fix is trivial/small and (where noted) adjacent to a blocking fix already being made this round, so a separate issue would cost more ceremony than the fix itself." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "The 'detected' record already carries intent, cause and ETA, so a retrospective reader sees the incident and the schedule; supervisor crash-consistency beyond that is the PREQ's explicit HA non-goal. No incremental value over the existing record given the out-of-scope boundary. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "The 'detected' record already carries intent, cause and ETA, so a retrospective reader sees the incident and the schedule; supervisor crash-consistency beyond that is the PREQ's explicit HA non-goal. No incremental value over the existing record given the out-of-scope boundary. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "setsid is present on effectively every Linux box this suite targets (the fallback exists for exotic environments); the failure needs no-setsid AND detach-during-in-flight-resume. The stand-down record already prints loudly. No practical value in hardening the fallback's kill semantics. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "setsid is present on effectively every Linux box this suite targets (the fallback exists for exotic environments); the failure needs no-setsid AND detach-during-in-flight-resume. The stand-down record already prints loudly. No practical value in hardening the fallback's kill semantics. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "Deliberate graceful degradation: refusing outright on such boxes would break attach entirely, and the conservative direction (refuse attach) is the safe one. The exposure window requires an exotic box plus pid reuse landing on the recorded pid. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "Deliberate graceful degradation: refusing outright on such boxes would break attach entirely, and the conservative direction (refuse attach) is the safe one. The exposure window requires an exotic box plus pid reuse landing on the recorded pid. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "Requires a nonsense declaration; non-numeric values already warn-and-default; the retry bound contains the blast radius. No practical value. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "Requires a nonsense declaration; non-numeric values already warn-and-default; the retry bound contains the blast radius. No practical value. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "The SREQ risk table already covers quota-text variants with exactly this mitigation (bounded-retry, escalate); the terminal state is safe and loud. Improving weekly handling has no defined correct schedule to aim at (the text names no day). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "The SREQ risk table already covers quota-text variants with exactly this mitigation (bounded-retry, escalate); the terminal state is safe and loud. Improving weekly handling has no defined correct schedule to aim at (the text names no day). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "Each is real but the operative guards (resume count check, AC-13b canary) already cover the outcomes; none can green-light a product defect on its own. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "Each is real but the operative guards (resume count check, AC-13b canary) already cover the outcomes; none can green-light a product defect on its own. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "SREQ-compliant as written ('validated: exists, matches attach-time record'): the value is captured ONCE at attach — an operator-present moment, invoked by the driver itself — and never re-read from the transcript during watch, so exploiting it requires poisoning the transcript before engagement. A prefix check against project root risks false refusals on legitimate worktree layouts. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "SREQ-compliant as written ('validated: exists, matches attach-time record'): the value is captured ONCE at attach — an operator-present moment, invoked by the driver itself — and never re-read from the transcript during watch, so exploiting it requires poisoning the transcript before engagement. A prefix check against project root risks false refusals on legitimate worktree layouts. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 18:14:56 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "Identical to the house pattern: _shared/procedures/bin/_lib.sh's _read_forge_adapter parses the forge: block with the same non-fence-aware awk, and the repo's fence-aware rule is scoped to repo tools that scan skill markdown, not declared-block readers. The declared-block schema rules place the parseability burden on the declaration. A suite-wide fence-aware declared-block reader would be its own change touching every adapter. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "Identical to the house pattern: _shared/procedures/bin/_lib.sh's _read_forge_adapter parses the forge: block with the same non-fence-aware awk, and the repo's fence-aware rule is scoped to repo tools that scan skill markdown, not declared-block readers. The declared-block schema rules place the parseability burden on the declaration. A suite-wide fence-aware declared-block reader would be its own change touching every adapter. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "The helper tier's bash>=3.2 prerequisite already excludes busybox-class boxes in practice (they lack bash too), and every targeted platform's sleep accepts fractions. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "The helper tier's bash>=3.2 prerequisite already excludes busybox-class boxes in practice (they lack bash too), and every targeted platform's sleep accepts fractions. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; the choice follows the canonical recommender (finding.v1.md) computed from the finding's recorded axes, and a scope-disposition is non-blocking and latest-wins, so it is cheaply reversible.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — the finding's feature value is none (reasoned in the disposition rationale), so a backlog issue would only accumulate noise." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 18:16:27 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "defer-to-issue",
  "rationale": "Operator-facing misinformation in exactly the states where trust matters. Fix: branch on state.status — resume-in-flight explains the stale heartbeat; status 'starting' explains a null pid. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice follows the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes (fix_cost substantial => defer). Fold target judged per /dev:resolve's confidence rule: no existing issue covers supervisor-daemon robustness, so CR-21 spawns the home and CR-22/CR-24 fold into it (same daemon, same component).",
  "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — the fix is substantial (state-restore contract / lock-reclaim redesign / stall-window design) and would grow this QA round past its blocking set; the risk each finding names is bounded and rare."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "defer-to-issue", "rationale": "Operator-facing misinformation in exactly the states where trust matters. Fix: branch on state.status — resume-in-flight explains the stale heartbeat; status 'starting' explains a null pid. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice follows the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes (fix_cost substantial => defer). Fold target judged per /dev:resolve's confidence rule: no existing issue covers supervisor-daemon robustness, so CR-21 spawns the home and CR-22/CR-24 fold into it (same daemon, same component).", "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — the fix is substantial (state-restore contract / lock-reclaim redesign / stall-window design) and would grow this QA round past its blocking set; the risk each finding names is bounded and rare." } ```

jbr870 referenced this issue

2026-08-25 18:16:28 +00:00

supervise: daemon robustness edges — retry bound across re-attach, lock-reclaim TOCTOU, stall blind spots #255

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 18:16:29 +00:00

Author

Owner

Linked: this issue is sibling #255 (recorded by the devwork pipeline).

Linked: this issue is **sibling** #255 (recorded by the devwork pipeline).

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 18:16:29 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "defer-to-issue",
  "target_issue_ref": "255",
  "rationale": "Hygiene while the file is already under edit; delete it. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice follows the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes (fix_cost substantial => defer). Fold target judged per /dev:resolve's confidence rule: no existing issue covers supervisor-daemon robustness, so CR-21 spawns the home and CR-22/CR-24 fold into it (same daemon, same component).",
  "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — the fix is substantial (state-restore contract / lock-reclaim redesign / stall-window design) and would grow this QA round past its blocking set; the risk each finding names is bounded and rare."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "defer-to-issue", "target_issue_ref": "255", "rationale": "Hygiene while the file is already under edit; delete it. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice follows the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes (fix_cost substantial => defer). Fold target judged per /dev:resolve's confidence rule: no existing issue covers supervisor-daemon robustness, so CR-21 spawns the home and CR-22/CR-24 fold into it (same daemon, same component).", "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — the fix is substantial (state-restore contract / lock-reclaim redesign / stall-window design) and would grow this QA round past its blocking set; the risk each finding names is bounded and rare." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 18:16:31 +00:00

Author

Owner

Linked: this issue is sibling #255 (recorded by the devwork pipeline).

Linked: this issue is **sibling** #255 (recorded by the devwork pipeline).

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 18:16:32 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "defer-to-issue",
  "target_issue_ref": "255",
  "rationale": "Mechanism verified, likelihood low (requires concurrent attaches racing a dead holder). Fix needs holder-identity-aware reclaim (e.g. write holder pid into the lock dir and verify-before-remove, or rename-based reclaim) — its own considered change with a test. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice follows the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes (fix_cost substantial => defer). Fold target judged per /dev:resolve's confidence rule: no existing issue covers supervisor-daemon robustness, so CR-21 spawns the home and CR-22/CR-24 fold into it (same daemon, same component).",
  "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — the fix is substantial (state-restore contract / lock-reclaim redesign / stall-window design) and would grow this QA round past its blocking set; the risk each finding names is bounded and rare."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "defer-to-issue", "target_issue_ref": "255", "rationale": "Mechanism verified, likelihood low (requires concurrent attaches racing a dead holder). Fix needs holder-identity-aware reclaim (e.g. write holder pid into the lock dir and verify-before-remove, or rename-based reclaim) — its own considered change with a test. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice follows the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes (fix_cost substantial => defer). Fold target judged per /dev:resolve's confidence rule: no existing issue covers supervisor-daemon robustness, so CR-21 spawns the home and CR-22/CR-24 fold into it (same daemon, same component).", "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — the fix is substantial (state-restore contract / lock-reclaim redesign / stall-window design) and would grow this QA round past its blocking set; the risk each finding names is bounded and rare." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 18:35:00 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "outcome": "clean",
  "summary": "12 red regression scenarios added for the promoted set (CR-1,3,4,5,7,8,9,10,12,13,14,23); CR-1 and CR-4 proven able to fail against current code; CR-12 is a green guard by nature (TOCTOU window unobservable black-box — valid regression guard, cannot be red pre-fix). Suite + lint green with guards in place. Doc/test-file findings (CR-2,6,11,15,16,17,18,19,20) need no separate red test: the fix edits the test/doc artifact itself, verified by the re-validate run and mechanical gates.",
  "findings": [],
  "artifacts": {
    "test_files": [
      "plugin/skills/supervise/test/supervisor-flow.sh"
    ],
    "test_commit": "1512dc8",
    "test_marker": {
      "runner": "bespoke-shell-harness",
      "write": "first line of scenario fn: echo \"SKIP-RED - <CR-ID> unfixed (promote: delete this line)\"; return 0",
      "promote": "delete that one guard line; never touch the assertions below it"
    }
  }
}

```json { "outcome": "clean", "summary": "12 red regression scenarios added for the promoted set (CR-1,3,4,5,7,8,9,10,12,13,14,23); CR-1 and CR-4 proven able to fail against current code; CR-12 is a green guard by nature (TOCTOU window unobservable black-box — valid regression guard, cannot be red pre-fix). Suite + lint green with guards in place. Doc/test-file findings (CR-2,6,11,15,16,17,18,19,20) need no separate red test: the fix edits the test/doc artifact itself, verified by the re-validate run and mechanical gates.", "findings": [], "artifacts": { "test_files": [ "plugin/skills/supervise/test/supervisor-flow.sh" ], "test_commit": "1512dc8", "test_marker": { "runner": "bespoke-shell-harness", "write": "first line of scenario fn: echo \"SKIP-RED - <CR-ID> unfixed (promote: delete this line)\"; return 0", "promote": "delete that one guard line; never touch the assertions below it" } } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 19:29:49 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "outcome": "clean",
  "summary": "All 23 in-scope findings fixed (CR-1..CR-20, CR-23; commits d018dd7 + f1b306c). 11 red tests promoted by guard deletion; CR-8 re-armed on an event-based wait and red-proven against a reverted fix. Assertion-constraint check vs test_commit 1512dc8: inside CR scenarios only guard lines changed. Fixer deviations flagged for the sweep adversarial pass: (a) attach record cause changed to operator-attach; (b) resumes now require the tail signature unchanged twice, one poll apart; (c) a foreign write found at pre-resume re-classification stands the supervisor down (operator-stop) rather than re-aiming. Gates: supervise suite 142 ok / 0 FAIL (independently re-run by the lead), lint clean, smoke PASS.",
  "findings": [],
  "artifacts": {
    "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md"
  }
}

```json { "outcome": "clean", "summary": "All 23 in-scope findings fixed (CR-1..CR-20, CR-23; commits d018dd7 + f1b306c). 11 red tests promoted by guard deletion; CR-8 re-armed on an event-based wait and red-proven against a reverted fix. Assertion-constraint check vs test_commit 1512dc8: inside CR scenarios only guard lines changed. Fixer deviations flagged for the sweep adversarial pass: (a) attach record cause changed to operator-attach; (b) resumes now require the tail signature unchanged twice, one poll apart; (c) a foreign write found at pre-resume re-classification stands the supervisor down (operator-stop) rather than re-aiming. Gates: supervise suite 142 ok / 0 FAIL (independently re-run by the lead), lint clean, smoke PASS.", "findings": [], "artifacts": { "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md" } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 19:40:06 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "outcome": "issues-found",
  "summary": "Round-2 fresh-context re-validation of the round-1 fixes: all 21 prior findings independently RESOLVED; 2 new low-severity findings (CR-34 residual arg-parse gap in need_value; CR-35 SKILL.md drift on the two new daemon behaviors). The fixer round-1 deviations (operator-attach cause, two-look stability gate, foreign-write standdown) were independently assessed sound.",
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "CR-34",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "need_value() (added by round 1 for CR-4) guards only a flag at end-of-argv: a flag followed by another flag, e.g. `supervisor-attach.sh --session --issue 46`, silently sets SESSION='--issue' (the charset check permits '-') and misparses instead of erroring.",
      "reasoning": "Residual of the CR-4 class found by the fresh-context re-validation: no hang, but a silent misparse at the same seam. Trivial: reject a value starting with '--' in need_value (no legitimate value of these flags starts with '--').",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "core"
    },
    {
      "id": "CR-35",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "SKILL.md's classification/behavior text does not document two behaviors round 1 added to the daemon: the pre-resume foreign-write standdown (a non-interrupt user record found at re-classification stands the supervisor down as operator-stop) and the two-consecutive-stable-observations requirement before any resume fires.",
      "reasoning": "In this suite the skill markdown IS the product; behavior the helpers have but the skill text does not describe is drift a future amendment round would misread. Small text addition to the classification section.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "core"
    }
  ],
  "artifacts": {
    "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md"
  }
}

```json { "outcome": "issues-found", "summary": "Round-2 fresh-context re-validation of the round-1 fixes: all 21 prior findings independently RESOLVED; 2 new low-severity findings (CR-34 residual arg-parse gap in need_value; CR-35 SKILL.md drift on the two new daemon behaviors). The fixer round-1 deviations (operator-attach cause, two-look stability gate, foreign-write standdown) were independently assessed sound.", "findings": [ { "id": "CR-34", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "need_value() (added by round 1 for CR-4) guards only a flag at end-of-argv: a flag followed by another flag, e.g. `supervisor-attach.sh --session --issue 46`, silently sets SESSION='--issue' (the charset check permits '-') and misparses instead of erroring.", "reasoning": "Residual of the CR-4 class found by the fresh-context re-validation: no hang, but a silent misparse at the same seam. Trivial: reject a value starting with '--' in need_value (no legitimate value of these flags starts with '--').", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "core" }, { "id": "CR-35", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "SKILL.md's classification/behavior text does not document two behaviors round 1 added to the daemon: the pre-resume foreign-write standdown (a non-interrupt user record found at re-classification stands the supervisor down as operator-stop) and the two-consecutive-stable-observations requirement before any resume fires.", "reasoning": "In this suite the skill markdown IS the product; behavior the helpers have but the skill text does not describe is drift a future amendment round would misread. Small text addition to the classification section.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "core" } ], "artifacts": { "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md" } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 19:40:07 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "outcome": "issues-found",
  "summary": "Validation run (test-plan:v1, 13 scenarios) over the declared shell integration lane — this project has no browser, so the e2e slot carries the PREQ-derived validation run. Suite fresh run: 147 ok / 0 FAIL; supervisor-event records verified legible by a real read of posted records. 8 scenarios PASS; 5 coverage gaps vs plan text recorded as V-1..V-5 (backoff growth unexercised; future-reset live fire uncovered by design; past-reset record value unasserted; AC-11 sweep mislabeled population; stall-override test lacks discriminating power). AC-13/AC-14 suite groups trace to SREQ expert-review ACs — legitimate, not scope creep.",
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "V-1",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "medium",
      "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 1 step 5 (attempt gaps GROW) is unexercised: every suite scenario declares backoff_multiplier=1, so exponential backoff (base x multiplier^n, the documented default shape) is never observed anywhere in the suite.",
      "reasoning": "Validation-run finding against plan text. Fix: one scenario (or an extension of AC-2's) with backoff_multiplier=2 and short base asserting the recorded ETAs/attempt spacing grow geometrically.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "small",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "core"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-2",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 3 step 5 (the run actually resumes at/promptly after a FUTURE reset time) is uncovered by design: scenario_ac3_future proves the scheduling math only and never lets the resume fire.",
      "reasoning": "The firing-at-ETA machinery is a single shared code path (next_eta + the now>=INC_ETA gate) proven live by AC-1/AC-2 at backoff ETAs and by AC-3b at an immediate quota ETA; the only untested increment is a wall-clock sleep to a minute-granularity future reset, costing 60s+ of suite runtime for a path composition already covers. Accept with this reasoning; the dogfood UAT run observes the real long-sleep behavior.",
      "proposed_action": "accept",
      "fix_cost": "substantial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "none"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-3",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 4 step 3 first clause: scenario_ac3_past never asserts the parsed reset value was RECORDED (only that the resume fired promptly with cause resumable-quota); AC-3a has the value assertion, the past variant does not.",
      "reasoning": "Trivial test addition: assert the detected record / state carries the parsed reset epoch in the past-variant too.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "incidental"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-4",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "medium",
      "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 12 step 2: AC-11's completeness sweep labeled 'sweep(AC-3)' actually re-inspects scenario_ac3_past's fixture (only it sets AC3_ISSUE/keep_sandbox); scenario_ac3_future is never completeness-swept, so the sweep silently covers Scenario 4 twice and Scenario 3 never.",
      "reasoning": "Validation-run finding: the sweep's population is mislabeled — a plan-text completeness claim quietly narrowed. Fix: keep the future variant's sandbox too and sweep both (or sweep future and relabel).",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "small",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "core"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-5",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "medium",
      "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 13: the stall-threshold override test cannot discriminate override from default — it ages the transcript exactly 30 minutes with stall_threshold_minutes=1 declared, but the suite DEFAULT threshold is also 30, so a supervisor ignoring the override would still alert at this boundary.",
      "reasoning": "Validation-run finding: zero discriminating power on the overridden tunable. Trivial: age the transcript ~5 minutes (over the 1-minute override, far under the 30-minute default) so an ignored override produces NO alert and the test fails.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "core"
    }
  ],
  "artifacts": {
    "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md"
  }
}

```json { "outcome": "issues-found", "summary": "Validation run (test-plan:v1, 13 scenarios) over the declared shell integration lane — this project has no browser, so the e2e slot carries the PREQ-derived validation run. Suite fresh run: 147 ok / 0 FAIL; supervisor-event records verified legible by a real read of posted records. 8 scenarios PASS; 5 coverage gaps vs plan text recorded as V-1..V-5 (backoff growth unexercised; future-reset live fire uncovered by design; past-reset record value unasserted; AC-11 sweep mislabeled population; stall-override test lacks discriminating power). AC-13/AC-14 suite groups trace to SREQ expert-review ACs — legitimate, not scope creep.", "findings": [ { "id": "V-1", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "medium", "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 1 step 5 (attempt gaps GROW) is unexercised: every suite scenario declares backoff_multiplier=1, so exponential backoff (base x multiplier^n, the documented default shape) is never observed anywhere in the suite.", "reasoning": "Validation-run finding against plan text. Fix: one scenario (or an extension of AC-2's) with backoff_multiplier=2 and short base asserting the recorded ETAs/attempt spacing grow geometrically.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "small", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "core" }, { "id": "V-2", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 3 step 5 (the run actually resumes at/promptly after a FUTURE reset time) is uncovered by design: scenario_ac3_future proves the scheduling math only and never lets the resume fire.", "reasoning": "The firing-at-ETA machinery is a single shared code path (next_eta + the now>=INC_ETA gate) proven live by AC-1/AC-2 at backoff ETAs and by AC-3b at an immediate quota ETA; the only untested increment is a wall-clock sleep to a minute-granularity future reset, costing 60s+ of suite runtime for a path composition already covers. Accept with this reasoning; the dogfood UAT run observes the real long-sleep behavior.", "proposed_action": "accept", "fix_cost": "substantial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "none" }, { "id": "V-3", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 4 step 3 first clause: scenario_ac3_past never asserts the parsed reset value was RECORDED (only that the resume fired promptly with cause resumable-quota); AC-3a has the value assertion, the past variant does not.", "reasoning": "Trivial test addition: assert the detected record / state carries the parsed reset epoch in the past-variant too.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "incidental" }, { "id": "V-4", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "medium", "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 12 step 2: AC-11's completeness sweep labeled 'sweep(AC-3)' actually re-inspects scenario_ac3_past's fixture (only it sets AC3_ISSUE/keep_sandbox); scenario_ac3_future is never completeness-swept, so the sweep silently covers Scenario 4 twice and Scenario 3 never.", "reasoning": "Validation-run finding: the sweep's population is mislabeled — a plan-text completeness claim quietly narrowed. Fix: keep the future variant's sandbox too and sweep both (or sweep future and relabel).", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "small", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "core" }, { "id": "V-5", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "medium", "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 13: the stall-threshold override test cannot discriminate override from default — it ages the transcript exactly 30 minutes with stall_threshold_minutes=1 declared, but the suite DEFAULT threshold is also 30, so a supervisor ignoring the override would still alert at this boundary.", "reasoning": "Validation-run finding: zero discriminating power on the overridden tunable. Trivial: age the transcript ~5 minutes (over the 1-minute override, far under the 30-minute default) so an ignored override produces NO alert and the test fails.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "core" } ], "artifacts": { "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md" } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 19:40:09 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "next_state": "qa",
  "produced": [
    {
      "kind": "qa-report",
      "ref": "1845",
      "summary": "code validate round 2: 21/21 round-1 findings independently resolved; 2 new low findings"
    },
    {
      "kind": "qa-report",
      "ref": "1846",
      "summary": "validation run over the shell lane: 147 ok / 0 FAIL; 5 plan-text coverage gaps (V-1..V-5)"
    }
  ],
  "findings": [
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "need_value() (added by round 1 for CR-4) guards only a flag at end-of-argv: a flag followed by another flag, e.g. `supervisor-attach.sh --session --issue 46`, silently sets SESSION='--issue' (the charset check permits '-') and misparses instead of erroring.",
      "reasoning": "Residual of the CR-4 class found by the fresh-context re-validation: no hang, but a silent misparse at the same seam. Trivial: reject a value starting with '--' in need_value (no legitimate value of these flags starts with '--').",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "core",
      "id": "F-PO-46-5-1"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "SKILL.md's classification/behavior text does not document two behaviors round 1 added to the daemon: the pre-resume foreign-write standdown (a non-interrupt user record found at re-classification stands the supervisor down as operator-stop) and the two-consecutive-stable-observations requirement before any resume fires.",
      "reasoning": "In this suite the skill markdown IS the product; behavior the helpers have but the skill text does not describe is drift a future amendment round would misread. Small text addition to the classification section.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "core",
      "id": "F-PO-46-5-2"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "medium",
      "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 1 step 5 (attempt gaps GROW) is unexercised: every suite scenario declares backoff_multiplier=1, so exponential backoff (base x multiplier^n, the documented default shape) is never observed anywhere in the suite.",
      "reasoning": "Validation-run finding against plan text. Fix: one scenario (or an extension of AC-2's) with backoff_multiplier=2 and short base asserting the recorded ETAs/attempt spacing grow geometrically.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "small",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "core",
      "id": "F-PO-46-5-3"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 3 step 5 (the run actually resumes at/promptly after a FUTURE reset time) is uncovered by design: scenario_ac3_future proves the scheduling math only and never lets the resume fire.",
      "reasoning": "The firing-at-ETA machinery is a single shared code path (next_eta + the now>=INC_ETA gate) proven live by AC-1/AC-2 at backoff ETAs and by AC-3b at an immediate quota ETA; the only untested increment is a wall-clock sleep to a minute-granularity future reset, costing 60s+ of suite runtime for a path composition already covers. Accept with this reasoning; the dogfood UAT run observes the real long-sleep behavior.",
      "proposed_action": "accept",
      "fix_cost": "substantial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "none",
      "id": "F-PO-46-5-4"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 4 step 3 first clause: scenario_ac3_past never asserts the parsed reset value was RECORDED (only that the resume fired promptly with cause resumable-quota); AC-3a has the value assertion, the past variant does not.",
      "reasoning": "Trivial test addition: assert the detected record / state carries the parsed reset epoch in the past-variant too.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "incidental",
      "id": "F-PO-46-5-5"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "medium",
      "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 12 step 2: AC-11's completeness sweep labeled 'sweep(AC-3)' actually re-inspects scenario_ac3_past's fixture (only it sets AC3_ISSUE/keep_sandbox); scenario_ac3_future is never completeness-swept, so the sweep silently covers Scenario 4 twice and Scenario 3 never.",
      "reasoning": "Validation-run finding: the sweep's population is mislabeled — a plan-text completeness claim quietly narrowed. Fix: keep the future variant's sandbox too and sweep both (or sweep future and relabel).",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "small",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "core",
      "id": "F-PO-46-5-6"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "medium",
      "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 13: the stall-threshold override test cannot discriminate override from default — it ages the transcript exactly 30 minutes with stall_threshold_minutes=1 declared, but the suite DEFAULT threshold is also 30, so a supervisor ignoring the override would still alert at this boundary.",
      "reasoning": "Validation-run finding: zero discriminating power on the overridden tunable. Trivial: age the transcript ~5 minutes (over the 1-minute override, far under the 30-minute default) so an ignored override produces NO alert and the test fails.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "core",
      "id": "F-PO-46-5-7"
    }
  ],
  "pending_decisions": [
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-5-1",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for CR-34: need_value() (added by round 1 for CR-4) guards only a flag at end-of-argv: a flag followed by another flag, e.g. `supervisor-attach.sh --session --issue 46`, s",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-1",
      "reasoning": "Residual of the CR-4 class found by the fresh-context re-validation: no hang, but a silent misparse at the same seam. Trivial: reject a value starting with '--' in need_value (no legitimate value of these flags starts with '--')."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-5-2",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for CR-35: SKILL.md's classification/behavior text does not document two behaviors round 1 added to the daemon: the pre-resume foreign-write standdown (a non-interrupt use",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-2",
      "reasoning": "In this suite the skill markdown IS the product; behavior the helpers have but the skill text does not describe is drift a future amendment round would misread. Small text addition to the classification section."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-5-3",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for V-1: Test-plan Scenario 1 step 5 (attempt gaps GROW) is unexercised: every suite scenario declares backoff_multiplier=1, so exponential backoff (base x multiplier^n,",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-3",
      "reasoning": "Validation-run finding against plan text. Fix: one scenario (or an extension of AC-2's) with backoff_multiplier=2 and short base asserting the recorded ETAs/attempt spacing grow geometrically."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-5-4",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for V-2: Test-plan Scenario 3 step 5 (the run actually resumes at/promptly after a FUTURE reset time) is uncovered by design: scenario_ac3_future proves the scheduling m",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "accept",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-4",
      "reasoning": "The firing-at-ETA machinery is a single shared code path (next_eta + the now>=INC_ETA gate) proven live by AC-1/AC-2 at backoff ETAs and by AC-3b at an immediate quota ETA; the only untested increment is a wall-clock sleep to a minute-granularity future reset, costing 60s+ of suite runtime for a path composition already covers. Accept with this reasoning; the dogfood UAT run observes the real long-sleep behavior."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-5-5",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for V-3: Test-plan Scenario 4 step 3 first clause: scenario_ac3_past never asserts the parsed reset value was RECORDED (only that the resume fired promptly with cause re",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-5",
      "reasoning": "Trivial test addition: assert the detected record / state carries the parsed reset epoch in the past-variant too."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-5-6",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for V-4: Test-plan Scenario 12 step 2: AC-11's completeness sweep labeled 'sweep(AC-3)' actually re-inspects scenario_ac3_past's fixture (only it sets AC3_ISSUE/keep_san",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-6",
      "reasoning": "Validation-run finding: the sweep's population is mislabeled — a plan-text completeness claim quietly narrowed. Fix: keep the future variant's sandbox too and sweep both (or sweep future and relabel)."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-5-7",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for V-5: Test-plan Scenario 13: the stall-threshold override test cannot discriminate override from default — it ages the transcript exactly 30 minutes with stall_thre",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-7",
      "reasoning": "Validation-run finding: zero discriminating power on the overridden tunable. Trivial: age the transcript ~5 minutes (over the 1-minute override, far under the 30-minute default) so an ignored override produces NO alert and the test fails."
    }
  ],
  "suite": {
    "source": "git",
    "sha": "2ceacfe8490eb7efb2258c1d62981eea06acb97b",
    "dirty": false
  }
}

```json { "next_state": "qa", "produced": [ { "kind": "qa-report", "ref": "1845", "summary": "code validate round 2: 21/21 round-1 findings independently resolved; 2 new low findings" }, { "kind": "qa-report", "ref": "1846", "summary": "validation run over the shell lane: 147 ok / 0 FAIL; 5 plan-text coverage gaps (V-1..V-5)" } ], "findings": [ { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "need_value() (added by round 1 for CR-4) guards only a flag at end-of-argv: a flag followed by another flag, e.g. `supervisor-attach.sh --session --issue 46`, silently sets SESSION='--issue' (the charset check permits '-') and misparses instead of erroring.", "reasoning": "Residual of the CR-4 class found by the fresh-context re-validation: no hang, but a silent misparse at the same seam. Trivial: reject a value starting with '--' in need_value (no legitimate value of these flags starts with '--').", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "core", "id": "F-PO-46-5-1" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "SKILL.md's classification/behavior text does not document two behaviors round 1 added to the daemon: the pre-resume foreign-write standdown (a non-interrupt user record found at re-classification stands the supervisor down as operator-stop) and the two-consecutive-stable-observations requirement before any resume fires.", "reasoning": "In this suite the skill markdown IS the product; behavior the helpers have but the skill text does not describe is drift a future amendment round would misread. Small text addition to the classification section.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "core", "id": "F-PO-46-5-2" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "medium", "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 1 step 5 (attempt gaps GROW) is unexercised: every suite scenario declares backoff_multiplier=1, so exponential backoff (base x multiplier^n, the documented default shape) is never observed anywhere in the suite.", "reasoning": "Validation-run finding against plan text. Fix: one scenario (or an extension of AC-2's) with backoff_multiplier=2 and short base asserting the recorded ETAs/attempt spacing grow geometrically.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "small", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "core", "id": "F-PO-46-5-3" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 3 step 5 (the run actually resumes at/promptly after a FUTURE reset time) is uncovered by design: scenario_ac3_future proves the scheduling math only and never lets the resume fire.", "reasoning": "The firing-at-ETA machinery is a single shared code path (next_eta + the now>=INC_ETA gate) proven live by AC-1/AC-2 at backoff ETAs and by AC-3b at an immediate quota ETA; the only untested increment is a wall-clock sleep to a minute-granularity future reset, costing 60s+ of suite runtime for a path composition already covers. Accept with this reasoning; the dogfood UAT run observes the real long-sleep behavior.", "proposed_action": "accept", "fix_cost": "substantial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "none", "id": "F-PO-46-5-4" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 4 step 3 first clause: scenario_ac3_past never asserts the parsed reset value was RECORDED (only that the resume fired promptly with cause resumable-quota); AC-3a has the value assertion, the past variant does not.", "reasoning": "Trivial test addition: assert the detected record / state carries the parsed reset epoch in the past-variant too.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "incidental", "id": "F-PO-46-5-5" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "medium", "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 12 step 2: AC-11's completeness sweep labeled 'sweep(AC-3)' actually re-inspects scenario_ac3_past's fixture (only it sets AC3_ISSUE/keep_sandbox); scenario_ac3_future is never completeness-swept, so the sweep silently covers Scenario 4 twice and Scenario 3 never.", "reasoning": "Validation-run finding: the sweep's population is mislabeled — a plan-text completeness claim quietly narrowed. Fix: keep the future variant's sandbox too and sweep both (or sweep future and relabel).", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "small", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "core", "id": "F-PO-46-5-6" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "medium", "summary": "Test-plan Scenario 13: the stall-threshold override test cannot discriminate override from default — it ages the transcript exactly 30 minutes with stall_threshold_minutes=1 declared, but the suite DEFAULT threshold is also 30, so a supervisor ignoring the override would still alert at this boundary.", "reasoning": "Validation-run finding: zero discriminating power on the overridden tunable. Trivial: age the transcript ~5 minutes (over the 1-minute override, far under the 30-minute default) so an ignored override produces NO alert and the test fails.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "core", "id": "F-PO-46-5-7" } ], "pending_decisions": [ { "id": "D-PO-46-5-1", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for CR-34: need_value() (added by round 1 for CR-4) guards only a flag at end-of-argv: a flag followed by another flag, e.g. `supervisor-attach.sh --session --issue 46`, s", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-1", "reasoning": "Residual of the CR-4 class found by the fresh-context re-validation: no hang, but a silent misparse at the same seam. Trivial: reject a value starting with '--' in need_value (no legitimate value of these flags starts with '--')." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-5-2", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for CR-35: SKILL.md's classification/behavior text does not document two behaviors round 1 added to the daemon: the pre-resume foreign-write standdown (a non-interrupt use", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-2", "reasoning": "In this suite the skill markdown IS the product; behavior the helpers have but the skill text does not describe is drift a future amendment round would misread. Small text addition to the classification section." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-5-3", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for V-1: Test-plan Scenario 1 step 5 (attempt gaps GROW) is unexercised: every suite scenario declares backoff_multiplier=1, so exponential backoff (base x multiplier^n,", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-3", "reasoning": "Validation-run finding against plan text. Fix: one scenario (or an extension of AC-2's) with backoff_multiplier=2 and short base asserting the recorded ETAs/attempt spacing grow geometrically." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-5-4", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for V-2: Test-plan Scenario 3 step 5 (the run actually resumes at/promptly after a FUTURE reset time) is uncovered by design: scenario_ac3_future proves the scheduling m", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "accept", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-4", "reasoning": "The firing-at-ETA machinery is a single shared code path (next_eta + the now>=INC_ETA gate) proven live by AC-1/AC-2 at backoff ETAs and by AC-3b at an immediate quota ETA; the only untested increment is a wall-clock sleep to a minute-granularity future reset, costing 60s+ of suite runtime for a path composition already covers. Accept with this reasoning; the dogfood UAT run observes the real long-sleep behavior." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-5-5", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for V-3: Test-plan Scenario 4 step 3 first clause: scenario_ac3_past never asserts the parsed reset value was RECORDED (only that the resume fired promptly with cause re", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-5", "reasoning": "Trivial test addition: assert the detected record / state carries the parsed reset epoch in the past-variant too." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-5-6", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for V-4: Test-plan Scenario 12 step 2: AC-11's completeness sweep labeled 'sweep(AC-3)' actually re-inspects scenario_ac3_past's fixture (only it sets AC3_ISSUE/keep_san", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-6", "reasoning": "Validation-run finding: the sweep's population is mislabeled — a plan-text completeness claim quietly narrowed. Fix: keep the future variant's sandbox too and sweep both (or sweep future and relabel)." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-5-7", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for V-5: Test-plan Scenario 13: the stall-threshold override test cannot discriminate override from default — it ages the transcript exactly 30 minutes with stall_thre", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-5-7", "reasoning": "Validation-run finding: zero discriminating power on the overridden tunable. Trivial: age the transcript ~5 minutes (over the 1-minute override, far under the 30-minute default) so an ignored override produces NO alert and the test fails." } ], "suite": { "source": "git", "sha": "2ceacfe8490eb7efb2258c1d62981eea06acb97b", "dirty": false } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 19:40:26 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Residual of the CR-4 class found by the fresh-context re-validation: no hang, but a silent misparse at the same seam. Trivial: reject a value starting with '--' in need_value (no legitimate value of these flags starts with '--'). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial/small edits in files this QA round is already touching."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Residual of the CR-4 class found by the fresh-context re-validation: no hang, but a silent misparse at the same seam. Trivial: reject a value starting with '--' in need_value (no legitimate value of these flags starts with '--'). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial/small edits in files this QA round is already touching." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 19:40:26 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "In this suite the skill markdown IS the product; behavior the helpers have but the skill text does not describe is drift a future amendment round would misread. Small text addition to the classification section. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial/small edits in files this QA round is already touching."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "In this suite the skill markdown IS the product; behavior the helpers have but the skill text does not describe is drift a future amendment round would misread. Small text addition to the classification section. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial/small edits in files this QA round is already touching." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 19:40:26 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Validation-run finding against plan text. Fix: one scenario (or an extension of AC-2's) with backoff_multiplier=2 and short base asserting the recorded ETAs/attempt spacing grow geometrically. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial/small edits in files this QA round is already touching."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Validation-run finding against plan text. Fix: one scenario (or an extension of AC-2's) with backoff_multiplier=2 and short base asserting the recorded ETAs/attempt spacing grow geometrically. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial/small edits in files this QA round is already touching." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "The firing-at-ETA machinery is a single shared code path (next_eta + the now>=INC_ETA gate) proven live by AC-1/AC-2 at backoff ETAs and by AC-3b at an immediate quota ETA; the only untested increment is a wall-clock sleep to a minute-granularity future reset, costing 60s+ of suite runtime for a path composition already covers. Accept with this reasoning; the dogfood UAT run observes the real long-sleep behavior. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — a 60s+ wall-clock sleep buys coverage of a code path already proven by composition (shared ETA-fire machinery + immediate-quota variant); the dogfood UAT run observes the real behavior."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "The firing-at-ETA machinery is a single shared code path (next_eta + the now>=INC_ETA gate) proven live by AC-1/AC-2 at backoff ETAs and by AC-3b at an immediate quota ETA; the only untested increment is a wall-clock sleep to a minute-granularity future reset, costing 60s+ of suite runtime for a path composition already covers. Accept with this reasoning; the dogfood UAT run observes the real long-sleep behavior. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — a 60s+ wall-clock sleep buys coverage of a code path already proven by composition (shared ETA-fire machinery + immediate-quota variant); the dogfood UAT run observes the real behavior." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Trivial test addition: assert the detected record / state carries the parsed reset epoch in the past-variant too. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial/small edits in files this QA round is already touching."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Trivial test addition: assert the detected record / state carries the parsed reset epoch in the past-variant too. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial/small edits in files this QA round is already touching." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Validation-run finding: the sweep's population is mislabeled — a plan-text completeness claim quietly narrowed. Fix: keep the future variant's sandbox too and sweep both (or sweep future and relabel). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial/small edits in files this QA round is already touching."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Validation-run finding: the sweep's population is mislabeled — a plan-text completeness claim quietly narrowed. Fix: keep the future variant's sandbox too and sweep both (or sweep future and relabel). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial/small edits in files this QA round is already touching." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 20:00:10 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Validation-run finding: zero discriminating power on the overridden tunable. Trivial: age the transcript ~5 minutes (over the 1-minute override, far under the 30-minute default) so an ignored override produces NO alert and the test fails. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial/small edits in files this QA round is already touching."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Validation-run finding: zero discriminating power on the overridden tunable. Trivial: age the transcript ~5 minutes (over the 1-minute override, far under the 30-minute default) so an ignored override produces NO alert and the test fails. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial/small edits in files this QA round is already touching." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "outcome": "clean",
  "summary": "Round 2: validation-gap coverage landed (V-1 geometric-backoff scenario; V-3 past-reset record assertion; V-4 AC-11 sweep now inspects both AC-3 variants, correctly labeled; V-5 stall-override test discriminates override from default) plus a red test for CR-34, red-proven with a live misparse reproduction (a daemon engaged under a state dir named --issue). Round-1 CR scenario assertions untouched. Suite rc=0 / 0 FAIL / 1 SKIP-RED (CR-34, pending fix); lint clean. Commit 6282755 (stacked on f1b306c).",
  "findings": [],
  "artifacts": {
    "test_files": [
      "plugin/skills/supervise/test/supervisor-flow.sh"
    ],
    "test_commit": "6282755",
    "test_marker": {
      "runner": "bespoke-shell-harness",
      "write": "first line of scenario fn: echo \"SKIP-RED - <ID> unfixed (promote: delete this line)\"; return 0",
      "promote": "delete that one guard line; never touch the assertions below it"
    }
  }
}

```json { "outcome": "clean", "summary": "Round 2: validation-gap coverage landed (V-1 geometric-backoff scenario; V-3 past-reset record assertion; V-4 AC-11 sweep now inspects both AC-3 variants, correctly labeled; V-5 stall-override test discriminates override from default) plus a red test for CR-34, red-proven with a live misparse reproduction (a daemon engaged under a state dir named --issue). Round-1 CR scenario assertions untouched. Suite rc=0 / 0 FAIL / 1 SKIP-RED (CR-34, pending fix); lint clean. Commit 6282755 (stacked on f1b306c).", "findings": [], "artifacts": { "test_files": [ "plugin/skills/supervise/test/supervisor-flow.sh" ], "test_commit": "6282755", "test_marker": { "runner": "bespoke-shell-harness", "write": "first line of scenario fn: echo \"SKIP-RED - <ID> unfixed (promote: delete this line)\"; return 0", "promote": "delete that one guard line; never touch the assertions below it" } } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 20:20:56 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "outcome": "issues-found",
  "summary": "Sweep adversarial pass (fable, fresh context, over fix commits d018dd7+c423585) found 1 blocking defect in the round-1 fix itself — a foreign write already present at incident open never gates the resume (S-1, CR-1 class recurrence; round 3 is framed at the class per the convergence rule) — plus 5 fix-now hardening items (S-3 quota re-clamp burn, S-5/S-6/S-7/S-9), 1 defer (S-4 abort-re-aim livelock, folding into #255), 1 accept (S-8 theoretical sig blind spots). Wide gates all green at c423585 (8 shared suites + supervise 159 ok + lint).",
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "S-1",
      "category": "in-scope-blocking",
      "severity": "high",
      "summary": "A foreign write already on the tail when the incident OPENS never triggers the operator-stop standdown: PRE_SIG is captured WITH the human's record (supervisor-watch.sh:320), the pre-fire guard (RE_SIG == PRE_SIG, class unchanged) passes, the abort branch that alone consults RE_FOREIGN (:361-373) is skipped, and the resume fires into a session a person wrote into. Nothing at loop-top or incident-open reads foreign_writes. SKILL.md:121-125 promises the standdown for exactly this case — the doc is right and the code is not.",
      "reasoning": "Second finding of the CR-1 class after the CR-1 fix — per the convergence rule this round is framed AT THE CLASS: foreign-write evidence gates resumes at EVERY classification of a resumable tail (the loop-top classification and the pre-fire re-classification), standing down as operator-stop whenever a non-tool-result, non-bookkeeping user record exists after the failed turn — regardless of whether the signature moved since scheduling. Verified by the lead against supervisor-watch.sh:311-373. The class framing, not a point patch at one more call site."
    },
    {
      "id": "S-3",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "medium",
      "summary": "The quota 'reset just passed' clamp applies on EVERY reschedule: the post-attempt path re-parses the fresh quota text the failed resume produced, and when it parses as just-passed (clock skew; weekly-limit texts naming a time-of-day days before the real reset), each reschedule clamps to immediate — attempts fire at ~2-poll spacing and burn the whole bound inside a still-closed window.",
      "reasoning": "Bounded and loud, but contradicts both 'backoff-spaced' and 'schedule against the stated clock', and each burned attempt is a real claude -p invocation. Fix: apply the just-passed immediate clamp only at incident OPEN (initial detection); on re-aim and post-attempt reschedules a just-passed parse falls back to backoff spacing.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "small",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": true,
      "feature_value": "core"
    },
    {
      "id": "S-4",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "A perpetually moving tail is a silent unbounded livelock: each ETA re-aims with INC_ATTEMPT unchanged, the retry bound never trips, and after the abort-record bound (3, or 1 when the pair repeats) further abort-re-aim cycles leave no record and no escalation — only supervisor-status.sh shows the incident is still churning.",
      "reasoning": "No writes and no spam, and an actively-moving tail does imply somebody/something is alive — but nothing bounds abort-re-aim cycles per incident, and silence after the record bound means an operator learns of a week-long churn only by running status. Needs a designed bound (does the incident terminate? escalate? at what count?) — same incident-lifecycle family as the #255 robustness edges.",
      "proposed_action": "defer-to-issue",
      "fix_cost": "substantial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "core"
    },
    {
      "id": "S-5",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "supervisor-watch.sh validates --session charset but not --issue, while the same fix round added digit + leading-zero validation to attach and detach — a hand-run daemon passes a hostile --issue straight into sup_event -> post-comment.sh.",
      "reasoning": "Mitigated by 'spawned by attach, never by hand', but the hardening is inconsistent within one round; copying the same check is trivial.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "incidental"
    },
    {
      "id": "S-6",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "A leading-zero numeric tunable (backoff_multiplier: 08) passes _sup_num_or_default's digits-only check, then explodes downstream: bash octal error at the (( < 1 )) guard, jq --argjson rejects 08 so STATE is empty, sup_state_write writes the empty document, the daemon exits at its no-state guard, and attach reports a misleading 'spawned but never reported a heartbeat' exit 5 after a 20s wait. st_num accepts '08' from state.json with the same octal hazard.",
      "reasoning": "The 0[0-9]* refusal added for --issue is missing from the tunable path. Trivial: reject-or-normalize leading zeros in _sup_num_or_default and st_num (warn + default, matching the existing non-numeric handling).",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "incidental"
    },
    {
      "id": "S-7",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "st_str's `getpath(...) // \"\" | tostring` swallows boolean false — clock_parse_capable: false reads back as \"\" not \"false\"; coincidentally correct today (only compared to \"true\") but silently corrupts any legitimately-false value a future reader pulls through it.",
      "reasoning": "Latent idiom bug in a shared accessor; trivial to express as an explicit null check instead of //.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "incidental"
    },
    {
      "id": "S-8",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "tail_sig blind spots: the record count saturates at the tail -n 400 window; a rewrite preserving the last record, a last record lacking both uuid and timestamp on both looks, or a non-JSON appended line is invisible to the guard; mtime is captured but never compared.",
      "reasoning": "Theoretical against an append-only harness store — every named case requires a rewriting writer the harness does not have. Recording it here is the value; hardening the signature belongs with the #255 lifecycle work if the store ever changes semantics.",
      "proposed_action": "accept",
      "fix_cost": "substantial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "none"
    },
    {
      "id": "S-9",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "supervisor-status.sh prints 'resume attempt $((attempt+1)) of $bound' — an exhausted incident awaiting its escalation poll reads 'attempt 6 of 5', and retry_bound=0 briefly reads 'attempt 1 of 0'.",
      "reasoning": "Operator-facing arithmetic cosmetic; clamp the display at the bound.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "incidental"
    }
  ],
  "artifacts": {
    "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md"
  }
}

```json { "outcome": "issues-found", "summary": "Sweep adversarial pass (fable, fresh context, over fix commits d018dd7+c423585) found 1 blocking defect in the round-1 fix itself — a foreign write already present at incident open never gates the resume (S-1, CR-1 class recurrence; round 3 is framed at the class per the convergence rule) — plus 5 fix-now hardening items (S-3 quota re-clamp burn, S-5/S-6/S-7/S-9), 1 defer (S-4 abort-re-aim livelock, folding into #255), 1 accept (S-8 theoretical sig blind spots). Wide gates all green at c423585 (8 shared suites + supervise 159 ok + lint).", "findings": [ { "id": "S-1", "category": "in-scope-blocking", "severity": "high", "summary": "A foreign write already on the tail when the incident OPENS never triggers the operator-stop standdown: PRE_SIG is captured WITH the human's record (supervisor-watch.sh:320), the pre-fire guard (RE_SIG == PRE_SIG, class unchanged) passes, the abort branch that alone consults RE_FOREIGN (:361-373) is skipped, and the resume fires into a session a person wrote into. Nothing at loop-top or incident-open reads foreign_writes. SKILL.md:121-125 promises the standdown for exactly this case — the doc is right and the code is not.", "reasoning": "Second finding of the CR-1 class after the CR-1 fix — per the convergence rule this round is framed AT THE CLASS: foreign-write evidence gates resumes at EVERY classification of a resumable tail (the loop-top classification and the pre-fire re-classification), standing down as operator-stop whenever a non-tool-result, non-bookkeeping user record exists after the failed turn — regardless of whether the signature moved since scheduling. Verified by the lead against supervisor-watch.sh:311-373. The class framing, not a point patch at one more call site." }, { "id": "S-3", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "medium", "summary": "The quota 'reset just passed' clamp applies on EVERY reschedule: the post-attempt path re-parses the fresh quota text the failed resume produced, and when it parses as just-passed (clock skew; weekly-limit texts naming a time-of-day days before the real reset), each reschedule clamps to immediate — attempts fire at ~2-poll spacing and burn the whole bound inside a still-closed window.", "reasoning": "Bounded and loud, but contradicts both 'backoff-spaced' and 'schedule against the stated clock', and each burned attempt is a real claude -p invocation. Fix: apply the just-passed immediate clamp only at incident OPEN (initial detection); on re-aim and post-attempt reschedules a just-passed parse falls back to backoff spacing.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "small", "adjacent_to_blocking": true, "feature_value": "core" }, { "id": "S-4", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "A perpetually moving tail is a silent unbounded livelock: each ETA re-aims with INC_ATTEMPT unchanged, the retry bound never trips, and after the abort-record bound (3, or 1 when the pair repeats) further abort-re-aim cycles leave no record and no escalation — only supervisor-status.sh shows the incident is still churning.", "reasoning": "No writes and no spam, and an actively-moving tail does imply somebody/something is alive — but nothing bounds abort-re-aim cycles per incident, and silence after the record bound means an operator learns of a week-long churn only by running status. Needs a designed bound (does the incident terminate? escalate? at what count?) — same incident-lifecycle family as the #255 robustness edges.", "proposed_action": "defer-to-issue", "fix_cost": "substantial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "core" }, { "id": "S-5", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "supervisor-watch.sh validates --session charset but not --issue, while the same fix round added digit + leading-zero validation to attach and detach — a hand-run daemon passes a hostile --issue straight into sup_event -> post-comment.sh.", "reasoning": "Mitigated by 'spawned by attach, never by hand', but the hardening is inconsistent within one round; copying the same check is trivial.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "incidental" }, { "id": "S-6", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "A leading-zero numeric tunable (backoff_multiplier: 08) passes _sup_num_or_default's digits-only check, then explodes downstream: bash octal error at the (( < 1 )) guard, jq --argjson rejects 08 so STATE is empty, sup_state_write writes the empty document, the daemon exits at its no-state guard, and attach reports a misleading 'spawned but never reported a heartbeat' exit 5 after a 20s wait. st_num accepts '08' from state.json with the same octal hazard.", "reasoning": "The 0[0-9]* refusal added for --issue is missing from the tunable path. Trivial: reject-or-normalize leading zeros in _sup_num_or_default and st_num (warn + default, matching the existing non-numeric handling).", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "incidental" }, { "id": "S-7", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "st_str's `getpath(...) // \"\" | tostring` swallows boolean false — clock_parse_capable: false reads back as \"\" not \"false\"; coincidentally correct today (only compared to \"true\") but silently corrupts any legitimately-false value a future reader pulls through it.", "reasoning": "Latent idiom bug in a shared accessor; trivial to express as an explicit null check instead of //.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "incidental" }, { "id": "S-8", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "tail_sig blind spots: the record count saturates at the tail -n 400 window; a rewrite preserving the last record, a last record lacking both uuid and timestamp on both looks, or a non-JSON appended line is invisible to the guard; mtime is captured but never compared.", "reasoning": "Theoretical against an append-only harness store — every named case requires a rewriting writer the harness does not have. Recording it here is the value; hardening the signature belongs with the #255 lifecycle work if the store ever changes semantics.", "proposed_action": "accept", "fix_cost": "substantial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "none" }, { "id": "S-9", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "supervisor-status.sh prints 'resume attempt $((attempt+1)) of $bound' — an exhausted incident awaiting its escalation poll reads 'attempt 6 of 5', and retry_bound=0 briefly reads 'attempt 1 of 0'.", "reasoning": "Operator-facing arithmetic cosmetic; clamp the display at the bound.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "incidental" } ], "artifacts": { "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md" } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 20:20:59 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "next_state": "qa",
  "produced": [
    {
      "kind": "qa-report",
      "ref": "1856",
      "summary": "sweep adversarial pass: 1 blocking (S-1 pre-open foreign write), 5 fix-now, 1 defer, 1 accept; wide gates green at c423585"
    }
  ],
  "findings": [
    {
      "category": "in-scope-blocking",
      "severity": "high",
      "summary": "A foreign write already on the tail when the incident OPENS never triggers the operator-stop standdown: PRE_SIG is captured WITH the human's record (supervisor-watch.sh:320), the pre-fire guard (RE_SIG == PRE_SIG, class unchanged) passes, the abort branch that alone consults RE_FOREIGN (:361-373) is skipped, and the resume fires into a session a person wrote into. Nothing at loop-top or incident-open reads foreign_writes. SKILL.md:121-125 promises the standdown for exactly this case — the doc is right and the code is not.",
      "reasoning": "Second finding of the CR-1 class after the CR-1 fix — per the convergence rule this round is framed AT THE CLASS: foreign-write evidence gates resumes at EVERY classification of a resumable tail (the loop-top classification and the pre-fire re-classification), standing down as operator-stop whenever a non-tool-result, non-bookkeeping user record exists after the failed turn — regardless of whether the signature moved since scheduling. Verified by the lead against supervisor-watch.sh:311-373. The class framing, not a point patch at one more call site.",
      "id": "F-PO-46-6-1"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "medium",
      "summary": "The quota 'reset just passed' clamp applies on EVERY reschedule: the post-attempt path re-parses the fresh quota text the failed resume produced, and when it parses as just-passed (clock skew; weekly-limit texts naming a time-of-day days before the real reset), each reschedule clamps to immediate — attempts fire at ~2-poll spacing and burn the whole bound inside a still-closed window.",
      "reasoning": "Bounded and loud, but contradicts both 'backoff-spaced' and 'schedule against the stated clock', and each burned attempt is a real claude -p invocation. Fix: apply the just-passed immediate clamp only at incident OPEN (initial detection); on re-aim and post-attempt reschedules a just-passed parse falls back to backoff spacing.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "small",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": true,
      "feature_value": "core",
      "id": "F-PO-46-6-2"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "A perpetually moving tail is a silent unbounded livelock: each ETA re-aims with INC_ATTEMPT unchanged, the retry bound never trips, and after the abort-record bound (3, or 1 when the pair repeats) further abort-re-aim cycles leave no record and no escalation — only supervisor-status.sh shows the incident is still churning.",
      "reasoning": "No writes and no spam, and an actively-moving tail does imply somebody/something is alive — but nothing bounds abort-re-aim cycles per incident, and silence after the record bound means an operator learns of a week-long churn only by running status. Needs a designed bound (does the incident terminate? escalate? at what count?) — same incident-lifecycle family as the #255 robustness edges.",
      "proposed_action": "defer-to-issue",
      "fix_cost": "substantial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "core",
      "id": "F-PO-46-6-3"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "supervisor-watch.sh validates --session charset but not --issue, while the same fix round added digit + leading-zero validation to attach and detach — a hand-run daemon passes a hostile --issue straight into sup_event -> post-comment.sh.",
      "reasoning": "Mitigated by 'spawned by attach, never by hand', but the hardening is inconsistent within one round; copying the same check is trivial.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "incidental",
      "id": "F-PO-46-6-4"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "A leading-zero numeric tunable (backoff_multiplier: 08) passes _sup_num_or_default's digits-only check, then explodes downstream: bash octal error at the (( < 1 )) guard, jq --argjson rejects 08 so STATE is empty, sup_state_write writes the empty document, the daemon exits at its no-state guard, and attach reports a misleading 'spawned but never reported a heartbeat' exit 5 after a 20s wait. st_num accepts '08' from state.json with the same octal hazard.",
      "reasoning": "The 0[0-9]* refusal added for --issue is missing from the tunable path. Trivial: reject-or-normalize leading zeros in _sup_num_or_default and st_num (warn + default, matching the existing non-numeric handling).",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "incidental",
      "id": "F-PO-46-6-5"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "st_str's `getpath(...) // \"\" | tostring` swallows boolean false — clock_parse_capable: false reads back as \"\" not \"false\"; coincidentally correct today (only compared to \"true\") but silently corrupts any legitimately-false value a future reader pulls through it.",
      "reasoning": "Latent idiom bug in a shared accessor; trivial to express as an explicit null check instead of //.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "incidental",
      "id": "F-PO-46-6-6"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "tail_sig blind spots: the record count saturates at the tail -n 400 window; a rewrite preserving the last record, a last record lacking both uuid and timestamp on both looks, or a non-JSON appended line is invisible to the guard; mtime is captured but never compared.",
      "reasoning": "Theoretical against an append-only harness store — every named case requires a rewriting writer the harness does not have. Recording it here is the value; hardening the signature belongs with the #255 lifecycle work if the store ever changes semantics.",
      "proposed_action": "accept",
      "fix_cost": "substantial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "none",
      "id": "F-PO-46-6-7"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "supervisor-status.sh prints 'resume attempt $((attempt+1)) of $bound' — an exhausted incident awaiting its escalation poll reads 'attempt 6 of 5', and retry_bound=0 briefly reads 'attempt 1 of 0'.",
      "reasoning": "Operator-facing arithmetic cosmetic; clamp the display at the bound.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "incidental",
      "id": "F-PO-46-6-8"
    }
  ],
  "pending_decisions": [
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-6-1",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for S-3: The quota 'reset just passed' clamp applies on EVERY reschedule: the post-attempt path re-parses the fresh quota text the failed resume produced, and when it pa",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-2",
      "reasoning": "Bounded and loud, but contradicts both 'backoff-spaced' and 'schedule against the stated clock', and each burned attempt is a real claude -p invocation. Fix: apply the just-passed immediate clamp only at incident OPEN (initial detection); on re-aim and post-attempt reschedules a just-passed parse falls back to backoff spacing."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-6-2",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for S-4: A perpetually moving tail is a silent unbounded livelock: each ETA re-aims with INC_ATTEMPT unchanged, the retry bound never trips, and after the abort-record b",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "defer-to-issue",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-3",
      "reasoning": "No writes and no spam, and an actively-moving tail does imply somebody/something is alive — but nothing bounds abort-re-aim cycles per incident, and silence after the record bound means an operator learns of a week-long churn only by running status. Needs a designed bound (does the incident terminate? escalate? at what count?) — same incident-lifecycle family as the #255 robustness edges."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-6-3",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for S-5: supervisor-watch.sh validates --session charset but not --issue, while the same fix round added digit + leading-zero validation to attach and detach — a hand-",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-4",
      "reasoning": "Mitigated by 'spawned by attach, never by hand', but the hardening is inconsistent within one round; copying the same check is trivial."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-6-4",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for S-6: A leading-zero numeric tunable (backoff_multiplier: 08) passes _sup_num_or_default's digits-only check, then explodes downstream: bash octal error at the (( < 1",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-5",
      "reasoning": "The 0[0-9]* refusal added for --issue is missing from the tunable path. Trivial: reject-or-normalize leading zeros in _sup_num_or_default and st_num (warn + default, matching the existing non-numeric handling)."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-6-5",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for S-7: st_str's `getpath(...) // \"\" | tostring` swallows boolean false — clock_parse_capable: false reads back as \"\" not \"false\"; coincidentally correct today (only ",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-6",
      "reasoning": "Latent idiom bug in a shared accessor; trivial to express as an explicit null check instead of //."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-6-6",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for S-8: tail_sig blind spots: the record count saturates at the tail -n 400 window; a rewrite preserving the last record, a last record lacking both uuid and timestamp ",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "accept",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-7",
      "reasoning": "Theoretical against an append-only harness store — every named case requires a rewriting writer the harness does not have. Recording it here is the value; hardening the signature belongs with the #255 lifecycle work if the store ever changes semantics."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-6-7",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for S-9: supervisor-status.sh prints 'resume attempt $((attempt+1)) of $bound' — an exhausted incident awaiting its escalation poll reads 'attempt 6 of 5', and retry_b",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-8",
      "reasoning": "Operator-facing arithmetic cosmetic; clamp the display at the bound."
    }
  ],
  "suite": {
    "source": "git",
    "sha": "2ceacfe8490eb7efb2258c1d62981eea06acb97b",
    "dirty": false
  }
}

```json { "next_state": "qa", "produced": [ { "kind": "qa-report", "ref": "1856", "summary": "sweep adversarial pass: 1 blocking (S-1 pre-open foreign write), 5 fix-now, 1 defer, 1 accept; wide gates green at c423585" } ], "findings": [ { "category": "in-scope-blocking", "severity": "high", "summary": "A foreign write already on the tail when the incident OPENS never triggers the operator-stop standdown: PRE_SIG is captured WITH the human's record (supervisor-watch.sh:320), the pre-fire guard (RE_SIG == PRE_SIG, class unchanged) passes, the abort branch that alone consults RE_FOREIGN (:361-373) is skipped, and the resume fires into a session a person wrote into. Nothing at loop-top or incident-open reads foreign_writes. SKILL.md:121-125 promises the standdown for exactly this case — the doc is right and the code is not.", "reasoning": "Second finding of the CR-1 class after the CR-1 fix — per the convergence rule this round is framed AT THE CLASS: foreign-write evidence gates resumes at EVERY classification of a resumable tail (the loop-top classification and the pre-fire re-classification), standing down as operator-stop whenever a non-tool-result, non-bookkeeping user record exists after the failed turn — regardless of whether the signature moved since scheduling. Verified by the lead against supervisor-watch.sh:311-373. The class framing, not a point patch at one more call site.", "id": "F-PO-46-6-1" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "medium", "summary": "The quota 'reset just passed' clamp applies on EVERY reschedule: the post-attempt path re-parses the fresh quota text the failed resume produced, and when it parses as just-passed (clock skew; weekly-limit texts naming a time-of-day days before the real reset), each reschedule clamps to immediate — attempts fire at ~2-poll spacing and burn the whole bound inside a still-closed window.", "reasoning": "Bounded and loud, but contradicts both 'backoff-spaced' and 'schedule against the stated clock', and each burned attempt is a real claude -p invocation. Fix: apply the just-passed immediate clamp only at incident OPEN (initial detection); on re-aim and post-attempt reschedules a just-passed parse falls back to backoff spacing.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "small", "adjacent_to_blocking": true, "feature_value": "core", "id": "F-PO-46-6-2" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "A perpetually moving tail is a silent unbounded livelock: each ETA re-aims with INC_ATTEMPT unchanged, the retry bound never trips, and after the abort-record bound (3, or 1 when the pair repeats) further abort-re-aim cycles leave no record and no escalation — only supervisor-status.sh shows the incident is still churning.", "reasoning": "No writes and no spam, and an actively-moving tail does imply somebody/something is alive — but nothing bounds abort-re-aim cycles per incident, and silence after the record bound means an operator learns of a week-long churn only by running status. Needs a designed bound (does the incident terminate? escalate? at what count?) — same incident-lifecycle family as the #255 robustness edges.", "proposed_action": "defer-to-issue", "fix_cost": "substantial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "core", "id": "F-PO-46-6-3" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "supervisor-watch.sh validates --session charset but not --issue, while the same fix round added digit + leading-zero validation to attach and detach — a hand-run daemon passes a hostile --issue straight into sup_event -> post-comment.sh.", "reasoning": "Mitigated by 'spawned by attach, never by hand', but the hardening is inconsistent within one round; copying the same check is trivial.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "incidental", "id": "F-PO-46-6-4" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "A leading-zero numeric tunable (backoff_multiplier: 08) passes _sup_num_or_default's digits-only check, then explodes downstream: bash octal error at the (( < 1 )) guard, jq --argjson rejects 08 so STATE is empty, sup_state_write writes the empty document, the daemon exits at its no-state guard, and attach reports a misleading 'spawned but never reported a heartbeat' exit 5 after a 20s wait. st_num accepts '08' from state.json with the same octal hazard.", "reasoning": "The 0[0-9]* refusal added for --issue is missing from the tunable path. Trivial: reject-or-normalize leading zeros in _sup_num_or_default and st_num (warn + default, matching the existing non-numeric handling).", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "incidental", "id": "F-PO-46-6-5" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "st_str's `getpath(...) // \"\" | tostring` swallows boolean false — clock_parse_capable: false reads back as \"\" not \"false\"; coincidentally correct today (only compared to \"true\") but silently corrupts any legitimately-false value a future reader pulls through it.", "reasoning": "Latent idiom bug in a shared accessor; trivial to express as an explicit null check instead of //.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "incidental", "id": "F-PO-46-6-6" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "tail_sig blind spots: the record count saturates at the tail -n 400 window; a rewrite preserving the last record, a last record lacking both uuid and timestamp on both looks, or a non-JSON appended line is invisible to the guard; mtime is captured but never compared.", "reasoning": "Theoretical against an append-only harness store — every named case requires a rewriting writer the harness does not have. Recording it here is the value; hardening the signature belongs with the #255 lifecycle work if the store ever changes semantics.", "proposed_action": "accept", "fix_cost": "substantial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "none", "id": "F-PO-46-6-7" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "supervisor-status.sh prints 'resume attempt $((attempt+1)) of $bound' — an exhausted incident awaiting its escalation poll reads 'attempt 6 of 5', and retry_bound=0 briefly reads 'attempt 1 of 0'.", "reasoning": "Operator-facing arithmetic cosmetic; clamp the display at the bound.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "incidental", "id": "F-PO-46-6-8" } ], "pending_decisions": [ { "id": "D-PO-46-6-1", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for S-3: The quota 'reset just passed' clamp applies on EVERY reschedule: the post-attempt path re-parses the fresh quota text the failed resume produced, and when it pa", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-2", "reasoning": "Bounded and loud, but contradicts both 'backoff-spaced' and 'schedule against the stated clock', and each burned attempt is a real claude -p invocation. Fix: apply the just-passed immediate clamp only at incident OPEN (initial detection); on re-aim and post-attempt reschedules a just-passed parse falls back to backoff spacing." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-6-2", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for S-4: A perpetually moving tail is a silent unbounded livelock: each ETA re-aims with INC_ATTEMPT unchanged, the retry bound never trips, and after the abort-record b", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "defer-to-issue", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-3", "reasoning": "No writes and no spam, and an actively-moving tail does imply somebody/something is alive — but nothing bounds abort-re-aim cycles per incident, and silence after the record bound means an operator learns of a week-long churn only by running status. Needs a designed bound (does the incident terminate? escalate? at what count?) — same incident-lifecycle family as the #255 robustness edges." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-6-3", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for S-5: supervisor-watch.sh validates --session charset but not --issue, while the same fix round added digit + leading-zero validation to attach and detach — a hand-", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-4", "reasoning": "Mitigated by 'spawned by attach, never by hand', but the hardening is inconsistent within one round; copying the same check is trivial." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-6-4", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for S-6: A leading-zero numeric tunable (backoff_multiplier: 08) passes _sup_num_or_default's digits-only check, then explodes downstream: bash octal error at the (( < 1", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-5", "reasoning": "The 0[0-9]* refusal added for --issue is missing from the tunable path. Trivial: reject-or-normalize leading zeros in _sup_num_or_default and st_num (warn + default, matching the existing non-numeric handling)." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-6-5", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for S-7: st_str's `getpath(...) // \"\" | tostring` swallows boolean false — clock_parse_capable: false reads back as \"\" not \"false\"; coincidentally correct today (only ", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-6", "reasoning": "Latent idiom bug in a shared accessor; trivial to express as an explicit null check instead of //." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-6-6", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for S-8: tail_sig blind spots: the record count saturates at the tail -n 400 window; a rewrite preserving the last record, a last record lacking both uuid and timestamp ", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "accept", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-7", "reasoning": "Theoretical against an append-only harness store — every named case requires a rewriting writer the harness does not have. Recording it here is the value; hardening the signature belongs with the #255 lifecycle work if the store ever changes semantics." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-6-7", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for S-9: supervisor-status.sh prints 'resume attempt $((attempt+1)) of $bound' — an exhausted incident awaiting its escalation poll reads 'attempt 6 of 5', and retry_b", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-6-8", "reasoning": "Operator-facing arithmetic cosmetic; clamp the display at the bound." } ], "suite": { "source": "git", "sha": "2ceacfe8490eb7efb2258c1d62981eea06acb97b", "dirty": false } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 20:21:21 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Bounded and loud, but contradicts both 'backoff-spaced' and 'schedule against the stated clock', and each burned attempt is a real claude -p invocation. Fix: apply the just-passed immediate clamp only at incident OPEN (initial detection); on re-aim and post-attempt reschedules a just-passed parse falls back to backoff spacing. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — small change adjacent to the S-1 class fix in the same scheduling helper."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Bounded and loud, but contradicts both 'backoff-spaced' and 'schedule against the stated clock', and each burned attempt is a real claude -p invocation. Fix: apply the just-passed immediate clamp only at incident OPEN (initial detection); on re-aim and post-attempt reschedules a just-passed parse falls back to backoff spacing. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — small change adjacent to the S-1 class fix in the same scheduling helper." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 20:21:21 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "defer-to-issue",
  "target_issue_ref": "255",
  "rationale": "No writes and no spam, and an actively-moving tail does imply somebody/something is alive — but nothing bounds abort-re-aim cycles per incident, and silence after the record bound means an operator learns of a week-long churn only by running status. Needs a designed bound (does the incident terminate? escalate? at what count?) — same incident-lifecycle family as the #255 robustness edges. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — the bound's semantics (terminate vs escalate, at what count) are a design choice belonging with the #255 incident-lifecycle work, not a point patch."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "defer-to-issue", "target_issue_ref": "255", "rationale": "No writes and no spam, and an actively-moving tail does imply somebody/something is alive — but nothing bounds abort-re-aim cycles per incident, and silence after the record bound means an operator learns of a week-long churn only by running status. Needs a designed bound (does the incident terminate? escalate? at what count?) — same incident-lifecycle family as the #255 robustness edges. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — the bound's semantics (terminate vs escalate, at what count) are a design choice belonging with the #255 incident-lifecycle work, not a point patch." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 20:21:24 +00:00

Author

Owner

Linked: this issue is sibling #255 (recorded by the devwork pipeline).

Linked: this issue is **sibling** #255 (recorded by the devwork pipeline).

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 20:21:24 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Mitigated by 'spawned by attach, never by hand', but the hardening is inconsistent within one round; copying the same check is trivial. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial copy of an existing check."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Mitigated by 'spawned by attach, never by hand', but the hardening is inconsistent within one round; copying the same check is trivial. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial copy of an existing check." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 20:21:24 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "The 0[0-9]* refusal added for --issue is missing from the tunable path. Trivial: reject-or-normalize leading zeros in _sup_num_or_default and st_num (warn + default, matching the existing non-numeric handling). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial extension of the existing numeric validation."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "The 0[0-9]* refusal added for --issue is missing from the tunable path. Trivial: reject-or-normalize leading zeros in _sup_num_or_default and st_num (warn + default, matching the existing non-numeric handling). — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial extension of the existing numeric validation." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 20:21:25 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Latent idiom bug in a shared accessor; trivial to express as an explicit null check instead of //. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial accessor fix."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Latent idiom bug in a shared accessor; trivial to express as an explicit null check instead of //. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial accessor fix." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 20:21:25 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "Theoretical against an append-only harness store — every named case requires a rewriting writer the harness does not have. Recording it here is the value; hardening the signature belongs with the #255 lifecycle work if the store ever changes semantics. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — every named case requires a rewriting writer the append-only harness store does not have; the record of the limitation is the value."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "Theoretical against an append-only harness store — every named case requires a rewriting writer the harness does not have. Recording it here is the value; hardening the signature belongs with the #255 lifecycle work if the store ever changes semantics. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — every named case requires a rewriting writer the append-only harness store does not have; the record of the limitation is the value." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 20:21:25 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Operator-facing arithmetic cosmetic; clamp the display at the bound. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial display clamp."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Operator-facing arithmetic cosmetic; clamp the display at the bound. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial display clamp." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 20:45:34 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "outcome": "clean",
  "summary": "Round 3: 4 red tests written and ALL proven red in isolation (S-1 pre-open foreign write -> 3 blind resumes, no standdown; S-3 clamp re-fires every reschedule; S-5 watch --issue hang rc=124; S-6 silent wrong multiplier 8 recorded, no branded warning — mechanism corrected for this box jq 1.8.1 lenient --argjson). Also: round-2 V-1 spacing assertion de-flaked (ratio -> absolute margin) after a real jitter flake surfaced in the full-suite run. Suite rc=0 / 0 FAIL / 4 SKIP-RED; lint clean. Commit dde93c7. S-7/S-9 are cosmetic accessor/display fixes with no dedicated red test — verified by re-validate.",
  "findings": [],
  "artifacts": {
    "test_files": [
      "plugin/skills/supervise/test/supervisor-flow.sh",
      "plugin/skills/supervise/test/fixtures/bin/claude"
    ],
    "test_commit": "dde93c7",
    "test_marker": {
      "runner": "bespoke-shell-harness",
      "write": "first line of scenario fn: echo \"SKIP-RED - <ID> unfixed (promote: delete this line)\"; return 0",
      "promote": "delete that one guard line; never touch the assertions below it"
    }
  }
}

```json { "outcome": "clean", "summary": "Round 3: 4 red tests written and ALL proven red in isolation (S-1 pre-open foreign write -> 3 blind resumes, no standdown; S-3 clamp re-fires every reschedule; S-5 watch --issue hang rc=124; S-6 silent wrong multiplier 8 recorded, no branded warning — mechanism corrected for this box jq 1.8.1 lenient --argjson). Also: round-2 V-1 spacing assertion de-flaked (ratio -> absolute margin) after a real jitter flake surfaced in the full-suite run. Suite rc=0 / 0 FAIL / 4 SKIP-RED; lint clean. Commit dde93c7. S-7/S-9 are cosmetic accessor/display fixes with no dedicated red test — verified by re-validate.", "findings": [], "artifacts": { "test_files": [ "plugin/skills/supervise/test/supervisor-flow.sh", "plugin/skills/supervise/test/fixtures/bin/claude" ], "test_commit": "dde93c7", "test_marker": { "runner": "bespoke-shell-harness", "write": "first line of scenario fn: echo \"SKIP-RED - <ID> unfixed (promote: delete this line)\"; return 0", "promote": "delete that one guard line; never touch the assertions below it" } } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 21:05:43 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "outcome": "clean",
  "summary": "Round 3 fixes landed (commit 8007611): S-1 fixed AT THE CLASS — foreign-write gating now runs at every classification of a resumable tail (loop-top + pre-fire, one shared helper), standing down as operator-stop before any incident/fire; S-3 just-passed clamp restricted to incident open via an explicit may_clamp flag; S-5 watch validates --issue; S-6 leading-zero tunables warn-and-default (state.json path refuses per CR-10 contract — deliberate asymmetry); S-7 st_str preserves false; S-9 status display clamped. All 4 guards promoted; assertion-constraint check: test diff is exactly the 4 guard deletions. Lead-verified gates: suite 174 ok / 0 FAIL / 0 SKIP-RED, lint clean, smoke PASS.",
  "findings": [],
  "artifacts": {
    "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md"
  }
}

```json { "outcome": "clean", "summary": "Round 3 fixes landed (commit 8007611): S-1 fixed AT THE CLASS — foreign-write gating now runs at every classification of a resumable tail (loop-top + pre-fire, one shared helper), standing down as operator-stop before any incident/fire; S-3 just-passed clamp restricted to incident open via an explicit may_clamp flag; S-5 watch validates --issue; S-6 leading-zero tunables warn-and-default (state.json path refuses per CR-10 contract — deliberate asymmetry); S-7 st_str preserves false; S-9 status display clamped. All 4 guards promoted; assertion-constraint check: test diff is exactly the 4 guard deletions. Lead-verified gates: suite 174 ok / 0 FAIL / 0 SKIP-RED, lint clean, smoke PASS.", "findings": [], "artifacts": { "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md" } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 21:14:45 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "outcome": "issues-found",
  "summary": "Second sweep adversarial pass over the round-3 fix (commit 8007611): the class fix holds at every gated site, BUT its interaction with the harness resume contract yields 1 blocking production-only defect (T-1: the supervisor own resume prompt is a plain user record — live-probed and confirmed — so an interrupted resume poisons the tail into a permanent false operator-stop on every re-attach; invisible to the suite because the stub omits the prompt record). Plus 2 trivial fix-nows (record-text accuracy T-2, status leading-zero sanitize T-4) and 1 reasoned accept (T-3 notify suppression on operator-stop). Wide gates all green at 8007611.",
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "T-1",
      "category": "in-scope-blocking",
      "severity": "high",
      "summary": "The supervisor's own resume prompt poisons the transcript against future supervision: a real `claude -p --resume` records its prompt as a plain user record (type:user, isMeta absent — CONFIRMED by live probe 2026-08-25, session 9b8f5b36, marker line included), which is_foreign_write has no exemption for. Any resume interrupted after the prompt-record write but before an assistant record lands (detach group-kill during resume-in-flight; daemon/box crash mid-resume; CLI failing after the append) leaves a tail every later attach classifies as a foreign write -> permanent false operator-stop standdown, exit 0, supervision silently unavailable until a human manually resumes. The suite is green because the stub claude never emulates the prompt user record and the recorded resume contract covered only the result envelope.",
      "reasoning": "Found by the second sweep's adversarial pass (F-1), confirmed by the lead's live probe (probe transcript preserved). Fix: is_foreign_write exempts user records whose text begins with the supervisor's own marker prefix '[run-supervisor resume — incident' (spoofing requires transcript write access — the same person the gate exists to detect, whose standdown is then their choice); the stub gains the real prompt-record emulation; the harness-resume-cli provenance/sample gain the recorded transcript-side shapes from the probe; red tests cover both the marker-record tail (must NOT stand down, resume proceeds) and the plain-user tail (must still stand down)."
    },
    {
      "id": "T-2",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "Record-text accuracy: the loop-top foreign-write standdown reuses record_abort's boilerplate claiming 'the transcript moved between scheduling this resume and acting on it (class X -> X, tail U -> U)' when the tail did not move; next_eta's non-clamp branch detail says 'the attempt just made' on a zero-attempt re-aim path.",
      "reasoning": "The forge record is the product's audit trail; a record asserting movement that did not happen misleads the retrospective reader the records exist for. Trivial text conditioning at both sites.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": true,
      "feature_value": "incidental"
    },
    {
      "id": "T-3",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "A foreign-write standdown (cause operator-stop) never fires the declared notify_command (maybe_notify only fires on escalate/alert), so an operator whose presence was inferred from a transcript write gets neither escalation nor notification.",
      "reasoning": "Designed semantic, and correct: an operator-stop standdown means a person is at the session — the forge record carries the event, and notifying the channel about the operator's own presence is noise. The compounding risk (F-1's false standdown never notifying) is removed by T-1's fix, after which every operator-stop standdown reflects a genuine human. Accept.",
      "proposed_action": "accept",
      "fix_cost": "small",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "none"
    },
    {
      "id": "T-4",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "supervisor-status.sh's numeric sanitize misses leading zeros: a hand-corrupted state attempt '08' throws a bash octal error to stderr and prints a garbled line.",
      "reasoning": "Read-only surface and hand-edit-only trigger, but the round's own theme is leading-zero hygiene and the sanitize half-applies it; trivial to strip/reject leading zeros in the same case statement.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "incidental"
    }
  ],
  "artifacts": {
    "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md"
  }
}

```json { "outcome": "issues-found", "summary": "Second sweep adversarial pass over the round-3 fix (commit 8007611): the class fix holds at every gated site, BUT its interaction with the harness resume contract yields 1 blocking production-only defect (T-1: the supervisor own resume prompt is a plain user record — live-probed and confirmed — so an interrupted resume poisons the tail into a permanent false operator-stop on every re-attach; invisible to the suite because the stub omits the prompt record). Plus 2 trivial fix-nows (record-text accuracy T-2, status leading-zero sanitize T-4) and 1 reasoned accept (T-3 notify suppression on operator-stop). Wide gates all green at 8007611.", "findings": [ { "id": "T-1", "category": "in-scope-blocking", "severity": "high", "summary": "The supervisor's own resume prompt poisons the transcript against future supervision: a real `claude -p --resume` records its prompt as a plain user record (type:user, isMeta absent — CONFIRMED by live probe 2026-08-25, session 9b8f5b36, marker line included), which is_foreign_write has no exemption for. Any resume interrupted after the prompt-record write but before an assistant record lands (detach group-kill during resume-in-flight; daemon/box crash mid-resume; CLI failing after the append) leaves a tail every later attach classifies as a foreign write -> permanent false operator-stop standdown, exit 0, supervision silently unavailable until a human manually resumes. The suite is green because the stub claude never emulates the prompt user record and the recorded resume contract covered only the result envelope.", "reasoning": "Found by the second sweep's adversarial pass (F-1), confirmed by the lead's live probe (probe transcript preserved). Fix: is_foreign_write exempts user records whose text begins with the supervisor's own marker prefix '[run-supervisor resume — incident' (spoofing requires transcript write access — the same person the gate exists to detect, whose standdown is then their choice); the stub gains the real prompt-record emulation; the harness-resume-cli provenance/sample gain the recorded transcript-side shapes from the probe; red tests cover both the marker-record tail (must NOT stand down, resume proceeds) and the plain-user tail (must still stand down)." }, { "id": "T-2", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "Record-text accuracy: the loop-top foreign-write standdown reuses record_abort's boilerplate claiming 'the transcript moved between scheduling this resume and acting on it (class X -> X, tail U -> U)' when the tail did not move; next_eta's non-clamp branch detail says 'the attempt just made' on a zero-attempt re-aim path.", "reasoning": "The forge record is the product's audit trail; a record asserting movement that did not happen misleads the retrospective reader the records exist for. Trivial text conditioning at both sites.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": true, "feature_value": "incidental" }, { "id": "T-3", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "A foreign-write standdown (cause operator-stop) never fires the declared notify_command (maybe_notify only fires on escalate/alert), so an operator whose presence was inferred from a transcript write gets neither escalation nor notification.", "reasoning": "Designed semantic, and correct: an operator-stop standdown means a person is at the session — the forge record carries the event, and notifying the channel about the operator's own presence is noise. The compounding risk (F-1's false standdown never notifying) is removed by T-1's fix, after which every operator-stop standdown reflects a genuine human. Accept.", "proposed_action": "accept", "fix_cost": "small", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "none" }, { "id": "T-4", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "supervisor-status.sh's numeric sanitize misses leading zeros: a hand-corrupted state attempt '08' throws a bash octal error to stderr and prints a garbled line.", "reasoning": "Read-only surface and hand-edit-only trigger, but the round's own theme is leading-zero hygiene and the sanitize half-applies it; trivial to strip/reject leading zeros in the same case statement.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "incidental" } ], "artifacts": { "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md" } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 21:14:48 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "next_state": "qa",
  "produced": [
    {
      "kind": "qa-report",
      "ref": "1870",
      "summary": "sweep 2: round-3 fix holds; 1 blocking harness-contract interaction (T-1, live-probed), 2 trivial fix-nows, 1 accept"
    }
  ],
  "findings": [
    {
      "category": "in-scope-blocking",
      "severity": "high",
      "summary": "The supervisor's own resume prompt poisons the transcript against future supervision: a real `claude -p --resume` records its prompt as a plain user record (type:user, isMeta absent — CONFIRMED by live probe 2026-08-25, session 9b8f5b36, marker line included), which is_foreign_write has no exemption for. Any resume interrupted after the prompt-record write but before an assistant record lands (detach group-kill during resume-in-flight; daemon/box crash mid-resume; CLI failing after the append) leaves a tail every later attach classifies as a foreign write -> permanent false operator-stop standdown, exit 0, supervision silently unavailable until a human manually resumes. The suite is green because the stub claude never emulates the prompt user record and the recorded resume contract covered only the result envelope.",
      "reasoning": "Found by the second sweep's adversarial pass (F-1), confirmed by the lead's live probe (probe transcript preserved). Fix: is_foreign_write exempts user records whose text begins with the supervisor's own marker prefix '[run-supervisor resume — incident' (spoofing requires transcript write access — the same person the gate exists to detect, whose standdown is then their choice); the stub gains the real prompt-record emulation; the harness-resume-cli provenance/sample gain the recorded transcript-side shapes from the probe; red tests cover both the marker-record tail (must NOT stand down, resume proceeds) and the plain-user tail (must still stand down).",
      "id": "F-PO-46-7-1"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "Record-text accuracy: the loop-top foreign-write standdown reuses record_abort's boilerplate claiming 'the transcript moved between scheduling this resume and acting on it (class X -> X, tail U -> U)' when the tail did not move; next_eta's non-clamp branch detail says 'the attempt just made' on a zero-attempt re-aim path.",
      "reasoning": "The forge record is the product's audit trail; a record asserting movement that did not happen misleads the retrospective reader the records exist for. Trivial text conditioning at both sites.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": true,
      "feature_value": "incidental",
      "id": "F-PO-46-7-2"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "A foreign-write standdown (cause operator-stop) never fires the declared notify_command (maybe_notify only fires on escalate/alert), so an operator whose presence was inferred from a transcript write gets neither escalation nor notification.",
      "reasoning": "Designed semantic, and correct: an operator-stop standdown means a person is at the session — the forge record carries the event, and notifying the channel about the operator's own presence is noise. The compounding risk (F-1's false standdown never notifying) is removed by T-1's fix, after which every operator-stop standdown reflects a genuine human. Accept.",
      "proposed_action": "accept",
      "fix_cost": "small",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "none",
      "id": "F-PO-46-7-3"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "supervisor-status.sh's numeric sanitize misses leading zeros: a hand-corrupted state attempt '08' throws a bash octal error to stderr and prints a garbled line.",
      "reasoning": "Read-only surface and hand-edit-only trigger, but the round's own theme is leading-zero hygiene and the sanitize half-applies it; trivial to strip/reject leading zeros in the same case statement.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "incidental",
      "id": "F-PO-46-7-4"
    }
  ],
  "pending_decisions": [
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-7-1",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for T-2: Record-text accuracy: the loop-top foreign-write standdown reuses record_abort's boilerplate claiming 'the transcript moved between scheduling this resume and a",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-7-2",
      "reasoning": "The forge record is the product's audit trail; a record asserting movement that did not happen misleads the retrospective reader the records exist for. Trivial text conditioning at both sites."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-7-2",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for T-3: A foreign-write standdown (cause operator-stop) never fires the declared notify_command (maybe_notify only fires on escalate/alert), so an operator whose presen",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "accept",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-7-3",
      "reasoning": "Designed semantic, and correct: an operator-stop standdown means a person is at the session — the forge record carries the event, and notifying the channel about the operator's own presence is noise. The compounding risk (F-1's false standdown never notifying) is removed by T-1's fix, after which every operator-stop standdown reflects a genuine human. Accept."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-7-3",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for T-4: supervisor-status.sh's numeric sanitize misses leading zeros: a hand-corrupted state attempt '08' throws a bash octal error to stderr and prints a garbled line.",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-7-4",
      "reasoning": "Read-only surface and hand-edit-only trigger, but the round's own theme is leading-zero hygiene and the sanitize half-applies it; trivial to strip/reject leading zeros in the same case statement."
    }
  ],
  "suite": {
    "source": "git",
    "sha": "2ceacfe8490eb7efb2258c1d62981eea06acb97b",
    "dirty": false
  }
}

```json { "next_state": "qa", "produced": [ { "kind": "qa-report", "ref": "1870", "summary": "sweep 2: round-3 fix holds; 1 blocking harness-contract interaction (T-1, live-probed), 2 trivial fix-nows, 1 accept" } ], "findings": [ { "category": "in-scope-blocking", "severity": "high", "summary": "The supervisor's own resume prompt poisons the transcript against future supervision: a real `claude -p --resume` records its prompt as a plain user record (type:user, isMeta absent — CONFIRMED by live probe 2026-08-25, session 9b8f5b36, marker line included), which is_foreign_write has no exemption for. Any resume interrupted after the prompt-record write but before an assistant record lands (detach group-kill during resume-in-flight; daemon/box crash mid-resume; CLI failing after the append) leaves a tail every later attach classifies as a foreign write -> permanent false operator-stop standdown, exit 0, supervision silently unavailable until a human manually resumes. The suite is green because the stub claude never emulates the prompt user record and the recorded resume contract covered only the result envelope.", "reasoning": "Found by the second sweep's adversarial pass (F-1), confirmed by the lead's live probe (probe transcript preserved). Fix: is_foreign_write exempts user records whose text begins with the supervisor's own marker prefix '[run-supervisor resume — incident' (spoofing requires transcript write access — the same person the gate exists to detect, whose standdown is then their choice); the stub gains the real prompt-record emulation; the harness-resume-cli provenance/sample gain the recorded transcript-side shapes from the probe; red tests cover both the marker-record tail (must NOT stand down, resume proceeds) and the plain-user tail (must still stand down).", "id": "F-PO-46-7-1" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "Record-text accuracy: the loop-top foreign-write standdown reuses record_abort's boilerplate claiming 'the transcript moved between scheduling this resume and acting on it (class X -> X, tail U -> U)' when the tail did not move; next_eta's non-clamp branch detail says 'the attempt just made' on a zero-attempt re-aim path.", "reasoning": "The forge record is the product's audit trail; a record asserting movement that did not happen misleads the retrospective reader the records exist for. Trivial text conditioning at both sites.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": true, "feature_value": "incidental", "id": "F-PO-46-7-2" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "A foreign-write standdown (cause operator-stop) never fires the declared notify_command (maybe_notify only fires on escalate/alert), so an operator whose presence was inferred from a transcript write gets neither escalation nor notification.", "reasoning": "Designed semantic, and correct: an operator-stop standdown means a person is at the session — the forge record carries the event, and notifying the channel about the operator's own presence is noise. The compounding risk (F-1's false standdown never notifying) is removed by T-1's fix, after which every operator-stop standdown reflects a genuine human. Accept.", "proposed_action": "accept", "fix_cost": "small", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "none", "id": "F-PO-46-7-3" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "supervisor-status.sh's numeric sanitize misses leading zeros: a hand-corrupted state attempt '08' throws a bash octal error to stderr and prints a garbled line.", "reasoning": "Read-only surface and hand-edit-only trigger, but the round's own theme is leading-zero hygiene and the sanitize half-applies it; trivial to strip/reject leading zeros in the same case statement.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "incidental", "id": "F-PO-46-7-4" } ], "pending_decisions": [ { "id": "D-PO-46-7-1", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for T-2: Record-text accuracy: the loop-top foreign-write standdown reuses record_abort's boilerplate claiming 'the transcript moved between scheduling this resume and a", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-7-2", "reasoning": "The forge record is the product's audit trail; a record asserting movement that did not happen misleads the retrospective reader the records exist for. Trivial text conditioning at both sites." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-7-2", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for T-3: A foreign-write standdown (cause operator-stop) never fires the declared notify_command (maybe_notify only fires on escalate/alert), so an operator whose presen", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "accept", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-7-3", "reasoning": "Designed semantic, and correct: an operator-stop standdown means a person is at the session — the forge record carries the event, and notifying the channel about the operator's own presence is noise. The compounding risk (F-1's false standdown never notifying) is removed by T-1's fix, after which every operator-stop standdown reflects a genuine human. Accept." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-7-3", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for T-4: supervisor-status.sh's numeric sanitize misses leading zeros: a hand-corrupted state attempt '08' throws a bash octal error to stderr and prints a garbled line.", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-7-4", "reasoning": "Read-only surface and hand-edit-only trigger, but the round's own theme is leading-zero hygiene and the sanitize half-applies it; trivial to strip/reject leading zeros in the same case statement." } ], "suite": { "source": "git", "sha": "2ceacfe8490eb7efb2258c1d62981eea06acb97b", "dirty": false } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 21:15:03 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "The forge record is the product's audit trail; a record asserting movement that did not happen misleads the retrospective reader the records exist for. Trivial text conditioning at both sites. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial text conditioning adjacent to the T-1 fix."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "The forge record is the product's audit trail; a record asserting movement that did not happen misleads the retrospective reader the records exist for. Trivial text conditioning at both sites. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial text conditioning adjacent to the T-1 fix." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 21:15:04 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "Designed semantic, and correct: an operator-stop standdown means a person is at the session — the forge record carries the event, and notifying the channel about the operator's own presence is noise. The compounding risk (F-1's false standdown never notifying) is removed by T-1's fix, after which every operator-stop standdown reflects a genuine human. Accept. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — notifying a channel about the operator's own presence is noise; the forge record carries the event, and T-1 removes the false-positive compound case."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "Designed semantic, and correct: an operator-stop standdown means a person is at the session — the forge record carries the event, and notifying the channel about the operator's own presence is noise. The compounding risk (F-1's false standdown never notifying) is removed by T-1's fix, after which every operator-stop standdown reflects a genuine human. Accept. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — notifying a channel about the operator's own presence is noise; the forge record carries the event, and T-1 removes the false-positive compound case." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 21:15:04 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Read-only surface and hand-edit-only trigger, but the round's own theme is leading-zero hygiene and the sanitize half-applies it; trivial to strip/reject leading zeros in the same case statement. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial sanitize extension in a file already under edit."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Read-only surface and hand-edit-only trigger, but the round's own theme is leading-zero hygiene and the sanitize half-applies it; trivial to strip/reject leading zeros in the same case statement. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — trivial sanitize extension in a file already under edit." } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 21:33:39 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "outcome": "clean",
  "summary": "Round 4: the harness resume contract now records the transcript-side prompt record (bare-string content, isMeta absent — from the live probe, session 9b8f5b36, 2026-08-25); the stub claude emulates it on every --resume (all prior scenarios still green under the more faithful stub); red test T-1a written and proven red (false operator-stop standdown on the supervisor own marker record, no resume fired); T-1b covered by the existing round-3 S-1 scenario, cross-referenced. Suite rc=0 / 0 FAIL / 1 SKIP-RED (T-1a); lint clean. Commit 799fe9f.",
  "findings": [],
  "artifacts": {
    "test_files": [
      "plugin/skills/supervise/test/supervisor-flow.sh",
      "plugin/skills/supervise/test/fixtures/bin/claude",
      "plugin/skills/supervise/test/fixtures/harness-resume-cli.sample.json",
      "plugin/skills/supervise/test/fixtures/harness-resume-cli.provenance.json"
    ],
    "test_commit": "799fe9f",
    "test_marker": {
      "runner": "bespoke-shell-harness",
      "write": "first line of scenario fn: echo \"SKIP-RED - <ID> unfixed (promote: delete this line)\"; return 0",
      "promote": "delete that one guard line; never touch the assertions below it"
    }
  }
}

```json { "outcome": "clean", "summary": "Round 4: the harness resume contract now records the transcript-side prompt record (bare-string content, isMeta absent — from the live probe, session 9b8f5b36, 2026-08-25); the stub claude emulates it on every --resume (all prior scenarios still green under the more faithful stub); red test T-1a written and proven red (false operator-stop standdown on the supervisor own marker record, no resume fired); T-1b covered by the existing round-3 S-1 scenario, cross-referenced. Suite rc=0 / 0 FAIL / 1 SKIP-RED (T-1a); lint clean. Commit 799fe9f.", "findings": [], "artifacts": { "test_files": [ "plugin/skills/supervise/test/supervisor-flow.sh", "plugin/skills/supervise/test/fixtures/bin/claude", "plugin/skills/supervise/test/fixtures/harness-resume-cli.sample.json", "plugin/skills/supervise/test/fixtures/harness-resume-cli.provenance.json" ], "test_commit": "799fe9f", "test_marker": { "runner": "bespoke-shell-harness", "write": "first line of scenario fn: echo \"SKIP-RED - <ID> unfixed (promote: delete this line)\"; return 0", "promote": "delete that one guard line; never touch the assertions below it" } } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 21:54:08 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "outcome": "clean",
  "summary": "Round 4 fixes landed (commit 3960bf5): T-1 own-resume-marker exemption in is_foreign_write — single shared SUP_RESUME_MARKER constant read by both the prompt builder and the classifier (cannot drift), matched against both recorded content shapes (bare string + typed array), spoofing tradeoff documented, SKILL.md updated; T-2 record texts now state only what actually happened at both sites; T-4 status sanitize covers leading zeros with an honest UNKNOWN on a corrupt bound. T-1a guard promoted; assertion-constraint check: test diff is exactly that one deletion. Lead-verified gates at 3960bf5: suite 178 ok / 0 FAIL / 0 SKIP-RED, lint clean. Deviation recorded: is_interrupt stays array-only (a bare-string interrupt falls through to the foreign gate -> same standdown outcome).",
  "findings": [],
  "artifacts": {
    "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md"
  }
}

```json { "outcome": "clean", "summary": "Round 4 fixes landed (commit 3960bf5): T-1 own-resume-marker exemption in is_foreign_write — single shared SUP_RESUME_MARKER constant read by both the prompt builder and the classifier (cannot drift), matched against both recorded content shapes (bare string + typed array), spoofing tradeoff documented, SKILL.md updated; T-2 record texts now state only what actually happened at both sites; T-4 status sanitize covers leading zeros with an honest UNKNOWN on a corrupt bound. T-1a guard promoted; assertion-constraint check: test diff is exactly that one deletion. Lead-verified gates at 3960bf5: suite 178 ok / 0 FAIL / 0 SKIP-RED, lint clean. Deviation recorded: is_interrupt stays array-only (a bare-string interrupt falls through to the foreign gate -> same standdown outcome).", "findings": [], "artifacts": { "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md" } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 22:01:46 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "outcome": "issues-found",
  "summary": "Third sweep adversarial pass over 3960bf5: the T-1 marker exemption holds under attack (anchored matching, byte-identical round trip, interrupt independence, safe stub direction) EXCEPT one regression it introduced — any_text propagates jq empty for a non-object message field, silently dropping unknown-shaped writers from foreign_writes (U-1, fail-open on the schema-drift seam; lead-verified by live jq repro; one-token fix). Plus U-3 (status sanitize incomplete, trivial fix-now) and three reasoned accepts (U-2 documented paste-quote tradeoff, U-4 pre-existing absent-bound default, U-5 cosmetic lede). Wide gates all green at 3960bf5.",
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "U-1",
      "category": "in-scope-blocking",
      "severity": "medium",
      "summary": "any_text's binding `(.message?.content?) as $c` (_supervisor-lib.sh:255) propagates jq `empty` when a user record's message field is a NON-OBJECT (string/number/array): the whole is_foreign_write chain evaluates to empty and select() silently DROPS the record from foreign_writes — confirmed by live jq reproduction. Pre-T-1 every helper was array-wrapped and total, so such a record counted as foreign; the fix regressed the schema-drift seam from fail-closed to fail-open: a drifted/malformed user record after the failed turn is an invisible writer and a resume can fire into a session someone is driving.",
      "reasoning": "No current harness shape triggers it (message is always an object today), but the SREQ's drift principle for this exact seam is fail-closed (classify on the minimal stable core, escalate on the unparseable — never guess past it). One-token fix: bind `(.message?.content? // null) as $c` (// maps empty to null), keeping every record total through the chain. Found by the third sweep, verified by the lead."
    },
    {
      "id": "U-2",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "The marker exemption is authorship-blind: an operator whose message begins with a pasted copy of the marker at position 0 is exempt from the foreign gate (their record still moves tail_sig -> abort+re-aim, and after two quiet polls the resume fires; any later plain record stands the supervisor down).",
      "reasoning": "Exactly the tradeoff T-1's fix documented in SKILL.md and in the code comment (write access to the transcript is the presence the gate detects); the realistic trigger is an accidental paste-quote, which the next plain record corrects. Optional future hardening (conjoin the recorded promptSource/entrypoint discriminators with the marker test) is noted on the record; not required.",
      "proposed_action": "accept",
      "fix_cost": "small",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "none"
    },
    {
      "id": "U-3",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "T-4's sanitize is incomplete within supervisor-status.sh itself: inc_eta (:112), hb (:83) and poll (:85) still reach bash arithmetic unsanitized (a hand-corrupted next_eta '08' prints the octal error where the status line belongs), and corrupt .incident.attempt silently coerces to 0 while corrupt bound gets the loud UNKNOWN — asymmetric honesty.",
      "reasoning": "Same class as T-4, same file, trivial: run every state number the script does arithmetic on through the same leading-zero-aware sanitize, and give a corrupt attempt the same honest treatment as a corrupt bound.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": true,
      "feature_value": "incidental"
    },
    {
      "id": "U-4",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "retry_bound ABSENT from state.json defaults to 0 in status (`// 0`), printing 'retry_bound is 0, so the incident escalates' while the daemon's actual default is 5 — reachable only on non-attach-written (older/hand-edited) state.",
      "reasoning": "Pre-existing default untouched by the rounds; attach always writes the field, so the path requires a hand-built state document. The honest-UNKNOWN pattern from T-4 could cover absence too, but absence-vs-corruption semantics on a machine-written file are #255's incident-lifecycle territory; not worth its own round here.",
      "proposed_action": "accept",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "none"
    },
    {
      "id": "U-5",
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "record_abort's 'moved' lede when the uuid is unchanged but the signature moved prints \"tail 'X' -> 'X'\", which reads as no movement — truthful but confusing.",
      "reasoning": "Cosmetic record style; the appended detail sentence carries the real cause. Not worth a fix round entry.",
      "proposed_action": "accept",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "none"
    }
  ],
  "artifacts": {
    "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md"
  }
}

```json { "outcome": "issues-found", "summary": "Third sweep adversarial pass over 3960bf5: the T-1 marker exemption holds under attack (anchored matching, byte-identical round trip, interrupt independence, safe stub direction) EXCEPT one regression it introduced — any_text propagates jq empty for a non-object message field, silently dropping unknown-shaped writers from foreign_writes (U-1, fail-open on the schema-drift seam; lead-verified by live jq repro; one-token fix). Plus U-3 (status sanitize incomplete, trivial fix-now) and three reasoned accepts (U-2 documented paste-quote tradeoff, U-4 pre-existing absent-bound default, U-5 cosmetic lede). Wide gates all green at 3960bf5.", "findings": [ { "id": "U-1", "category": "in-scope-blocking", "severity": "medium", "summary": "any_text's binding `(.message?.content?) as $c` (_supervisor-lib.sh:255) propagates jq `empty` when a user record's message field is a NON-OBJECT (string/number/array): the whole is_foreign_write chain evaluates to empty and select() silently DROPS the record from foreign_writes — confirmed by live jq reproduction. Pre-T-1 every helper was array-wrapped and total, so such a record counted as foreign; the fix regressed the schema-drift seam from fail-closed to fail-open: a drifted/malformed user record after the failed turn is an invisible writer and a resume can fire into a session someone is driving.", "reasoning": "No current harness shape triggers it (message is always an object today), but the SREQ's drift principle for this exact seam is fail-closed (classify on the minimal stable core, escalate on the unparseable — never guess past it). One-token fix: bind `(.message?.content? // null) as $c` (// maps empty to null), keeping every record total through the chain. Found by the third sweep, verified by the lead." }, { "id": "U-2", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "The marker exemption is authorship-blind: an operator whose message begins with a pasted copy of the marker at position 0 is exempt from the foreign gate (their record still moves tail_sig -> abort+re-aim, and after two quiet polls the resume fires; any later plain record stands the supervisor down).", "reasoning": "Exactly the tradeoff T-1's fix documented in SKILL.md and in the code comment (write access to the transcript is the presence the gate detects); the realistic trigger is an accidental paste-quote, which the next plain record corrects. Optional future hardening (conjoin the recorded promptSource/entrypoint discriminators with the marker test) is noted on the record; not required.", "proposed_action": "accept", "fix_cost": "small", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "none" }, { "id": "U-3", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "T-4's sanitize is incomplete within supervisor-status.sh itself: inc_eta (:112), hb (:83) and poll (:85) still reach bash arithmetic unsanitized (a hand-corrupted next_eta '08' prints the octal error where the status line belongs), and corrupt .incident.attempt silently coerces to 0 while corrupt bound gets the loud UNKNOWN — asymmetric honesty.", "reasoning": "Same class as T-4, same file, trivial: run every state number the script does arithmetic on through the same leading-zero-aware sanitize, and give a corrupt attempt the same honest treatment as a corrupt bound.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": true, "feature_value": "incidental" }, { "id": "U-4", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "retry_bound ABSENT from state.json defaults to 0 in status (`// 0`), printing 'retry_bound is 0, so the incident escalates' while the daemon's actual default is 5 — reachable only on non-attach-written (older/hand-edited) state.", "reasoning": "Pre-existing default untouched by the rounds; attach always writes the field, so the path requires a hand-built state document. The honest-UNKNOWN pattern from T-4 could cover absence too, but absence-vs-corruption semantics on a machine-written file are #255's incident-lifecycle territory; not worth its own round here.", "proposed_action": "accept", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "none" }, { "id": "U-5", "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "record_abort's 'moved' lede when the uuid is unchanged but the signature moved prints \"tail 'X' -> 'X'\", which reads as no movement — truthful but confusing.", "reasoning": "Cosmetic record style; the appended detail sentence carries the real cause. Not worth a fix round entry.", "proposed_action": "accept", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "none" } ], "artifacts": { "report_path": ".devwork/feature-46-run-supervisor/code-report.md" } } ```

jbr870 commented

2026-08-25 22:01:49 +00:00

Author

Owner

{
  "next_state": "qa",
  "produced": [
    {
      "kind": "qa-report",
      "ref": "1877",
      "summary": "sweep 3: T-1 fix holds; 1 blocking jq-totality regression (U-1, lead-verified), 1 trivial fix-now, 3 accepts"
    }
  ],
  "findings": [
    {
      "category": "in-scope-blocking",
      "severity": "medium",
      "summary": "any_text's binding `(.message?.content?) as $c` (_supervisor-lib.sh:255) propagates jq `empty` when a user record's message field is a NON-OBJECT (string/number/array): the whole is_foreign_write chain evaluates to empty and select() silently DROPS the record from foreign_writes — confirmed by live jq reproduction. Pre-T-1 every helper was array-wrapped and total, so such a record counted as foreign; the fix regressed the schema-drift seam from fail-closed to fail-open: a drifted/malformed user record after the failed turn is an invisible writer and a resume can fire into a session someone is driving.",
      "reasoning": "No current harness shape triggers it (message is always an object today), but the SREQ's drift principle for this exact seam is fail-closed (classify on the minimal stable core, escalate on the unparseable — never guess past it). One-token fix: bind `(.message?.content? // null) as $c` (// maps empty to null), keeping every record total through the chain. Found by the third sweep, verified by the lead.",
      "id": "F-PO-46-8-1"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "The marker exemption is authorship-blind: an operator whose message begins with a pasted copy of the marker at position 0 is exempt from the foreign gate (their record still moves tail_sig -> abort+re-aim, and after two quiet polls the resume fires; any later plain record stands the supervisor down).",
      "reasoning": "Exactly the tradeoff T-1's fix documented in SKILL.md and in the code comment (write access to the transcript is the presence the gate detects); the realistic trigger is an accidental paste-quote, which the next plain record corrects. Optional future hardening (conjoin the recorded promptSource/entrypoint discriminators with the marker test) is noted on the record; not required.",
      "proposed_action": "accept",
      "fix_cost": "small",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "none",
      "id": "F-PO-46-8-2"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "T-4's sanitize is incomplete within supervisor-status.sh itself: inc_eta (:112), hb (:83) and poll (:85) still reach bash arithmetic unsanitized (a hand-corrupted next_eta '08' prints the octal error where the status line belongs), and corrupt .incident.attempt silently coerces to 0 while corrupt bound gets the loud UNKNOWN — asymmetric honesty.",
      "reasoning": "Same class as T-4, same file, trivial: run every state number the script does arithmetic on through the same leading-zero-aware sanitize, and give a corrupt attempt the same honest treatment as a corrupt bound.",
      "proposed_action": "fix-now",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": true,
      "feature_value": "incidental",
      "id": "F-PO-46-8-3"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "retry_bound ABSENT from state.json defaults to 0 in status (`// 0`), printing 'retry_bound is 0, so the incident escalates' while the daemon's actual default is 5 — reachable only on non-attach-written (older/hand-edited) state.",
      "reasoning": "Pre-existing default untouched by the rounds; attach always writes the field, so the path requires a hand-built state document. The honest-UNKNOWN pattern from T-4 could cover absence too, but absence-vs-corruption semantics on a machine-written file are #255's incident-lifecycle territory; not worth its own round here.",
      "proposed_action": "accept",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "none",
      "id": "F-PO-46-8-4"
    },
    {
      "category": "in-scope-deferrable",
      "severity": "low",
      "summary": "record_abort's 'moved' lede when the uuid is unchanged but the signature moved prints \"tail 'X' -> 'X'\", which reads as no movement — truthful but confusing.",
      "reasoning": "Cosmetic record style; the appended detail sentence carries the real cause. Not worth a fix round entry.",
      "proposed_action": "accept",
      "fix_cost": "trivial",
      "adjacent_to_blocking": false,
      "feature_value": "none",
      "id": "F-PO-46-8-5"
    }
  ],
  "pending_decisions": [
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-8-1",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for U-2: The marker exemption is authorship-blind: an operator whose message begins with a pasted copy of the marker at position 0 is exempt from the foreign gate (their",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "accept",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-8-2",
      "reasoning": "Exactly the tradeoff T-1's fix documented in SKILL.md and in the code comment (write access to the transcript is the presence the gate detects); the realistic trigger is an accidental paste-quote, which the next plain record corrects. Optional future hardening (conjoin the recorded promptSource/entrypoint discriminators with the marker test) is noted on the record; not required."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-8-2",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for U-3: T-4's sanitize is incomplete within supervisor-status.sh itself: inc_eta (:112), hb (:83) and poll (:85) still reach bash arithmetic unsanitized (a hand-corrupt",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "fix-now",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-8-3",
      "reasoning": "Same class as T-4, same file, trivial: run every state number the script does arithmetic on through the same leading-zero-aware sanitize, and give a corrupt attempt the same honest treatment as a corrupt bound."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-8-3",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for U-4: retry_bound ABSENT from state.json defaults to 0 in status (`// 0`), printing 'retry_bound is 0, so the incident escalates' while the daemon's actual default is",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "accept",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-8-4",
      "reasoning": "Pre-existing default untouched by the rounds; attach always writes the field, so the path requires a hand-built state document. The honest-UNKNOWN pattern from T-4 could cover absence too, but absence-vs-corruption semantics on a machine-written file are #255's incident-lifecycle territory; not worth its own round here."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PO-46-8-4",
      "type": "scope-disposition",
      "blocking": false,
      "question": "Disposition for U-5: record_abort's 'moved' lede when the uuid is unchanged but the signature moved prints \"tail 'X' -> 'X'\", which reads as no movement — truthful but confusing.",
      "options": [
        "fix-now",
        "defer-to-issue",
        "accept"
      ],
      "recommended": "accept",
      "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-8-5",
      "reasoning": "Cosmetic record style; the appended detail sentence carries the real cause. Not worth a fix round entry."
    }
  ],
  "suite": {
    "source": "git",
    "sha": "2ceacfe8490eb7efb2258c1d62981eea06acb97b",
    "dirty": false
  }
}

```json { "next_state": "qa", "produced": [ { "kind": "qa-report", "ref": "1877", "summary": "sweep 3: T-1 fix holds; 1 blocking jq-totality regression (U-1, lead-verified), 1 trivial fix-now, 3 accepts" } ], "findings": [ { "category": "in-scope-blocking", "severity": "medium", "summary": "any_text's binding `(.message?.content?) as $c` (_supervisor-lib.sh:255) propagates jq `empty` when a user record's message field is a NON-OBJECT (string/number/array): the whole is_foreign_write chain evaluates to empty and select() silently DROPS the record from foreign_writes — confirmed by live jq reproduction. Pre-T-1 every helper was array-wrapped and total, so such a record counted as foreign; the fix regressed the schema-drift seam from fail-closed to fail-open: a drifted/malformed user record after the failed turn is an invisible writer and a resume can fire into a session someone is driving.", "reasoning": "No current harness shape triggers it (message is always an object today), but the SREQ's drift principle for this exact seam is fail-closed (classify on the minimal stable core, escalate on the unparseable — never guess past it). One-token fix: bind `(.message?.content? // null) as $c` (// maps empty to null), keeping every record total through the chain. Found by the third sweep, verified by the lead.", "id": "F-PO-46-8-1" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "The marker exemption is authorship-blind: an operator whose message begins with a pasted copy of the marker at position 0 is exempt from the foreign gate (their record still moves tail_sig -> abort+re-aim, and after two quiet polls the resume fires; any later plain record stands the supervisor down).", "reasoning": "Exactly the tradeoff T-1's fix documented in SKILL.md and in the code comment (write access to the transcript is the presence the gate detects); the realistic trigger is an accidental paste-quote, which the next plain record corrects. Optional future hardening (conjoin the recorded promptSource/entrypoint discriminators with the marker test) is noted on the record; not required.", "proposed_action": "accept", "fix_cost": "small", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "none", "id": "F-PO-46-8-2" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "T-4's sanitize is incomplete within supervisor-status.sh itself: inc_eta (:112), hb (:83) and poll (:85) still reach bash arithmetic unsanitized (a hand-corrupted next_eta '08' prints the octal error where the status line belongs), and corrupt .incident.attempt silently coerces to 0 while corrupt bound gets the loud UNKNOWN — asymmetric honesty.", "reasoning": "Same class as T-4, same file, trivial: run every state number the script does arithmetic on through the same leading-zero-aware sanitize, and give a corrupt attempt the same honest treatment as a corrupt bound.", "proposed_action": "fix-now", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": true, "feature_value": "incidental", "id": "F-PO-46-8-3" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "retry_bound ABSENT from state.json defaults to 0 in status (`// 0`), printing 'retry_bound is 0, so the incident escalates' while the daemon's actual default is 5 — reachable only on non-attach-written (older/hand-edited) state.", "reasoning": "Pre-existing default untouched by the rounds; attach always writes the field, so the path requires a hand-built state document. The honest-UNKNOWN pattern from T-4 could cover absence too, but absence-vs-corruption semantics on a machine-written file are #255's incident-lifecycle territory; not worth its own round here.", "proposed_action": "accept", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "none", "id": "F-PO-46-8-4" }, { "category": "in-scope-deferrable", "severity": "low", "summary": "record_abort's 'moved' lede when the uuid is unchanged but the signature moved prints \"tail 'X' -> 'X'\", which reads as no movement — truthful but confusing.", "reasoning": "Cosmetic record style; the appended detail sentence carries the real cause. Not worth a fix round entry.", "proposed_action": "accept", "fix_cost": "trivial", "adjacent_to_blocking": false, "feature_value": "none", "id": "F-PO-46-8-5" } ], "pending_decisions": [ { "id": "D-PO-46-8-1", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for U-2: The marker exemption is authorship-blind: an operator whose message begins with a pasted copy of the marker at position 0 is exempt from the foreign gate (their", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "accept", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-8-2", "reasoning": "Exactly the tradeoff T-1's fix documented in SKILL.md and in the code comment (write access to the transcript is the presence the gate detects); the realistic trigger is an accidental paste-quote, which the next plain record corrects. Optional future hardening (conjoin the recorded promptSource/entrypoint discriminators with the marker test) is noted on the record; not required." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-8-2", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for U-3: T-4's sanitize is incomplete within supervisor-status.sh itself: inc_eta (:112), hb (:83) and poll (:85) still reach bash arithmetic unsanitized (a hand-corrupt", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "fix-now", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-8-3", "reasoning": "Same class as T-4, same file, trivial: run every state number the script does arithmetic on through the same leading-zero-aware sanitize, and give a corrupt attempt the same honest treatment as a corrupt bound." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-8-3", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for U-4: retry_bound ABSENT from state.json defaults to 0 in status (`// 0`), printing 'retry_bound is 0, so the incident escalates' while the daemon's actual default is", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "accept", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-8-4", "reasoning": "Pre-existing default untouched by the rounds; attach always writes the field, so the path requires a hand-built state document. The honest-UNKNOWN pattern from T-4 could cover absence too, but absence-vs-corruption semantics on a machine-written file are #255's incident-lifecycle territory; not worth its own round here." }, { "id": "D-PO-46-8-4", "type": "scope-disposition", "blocking": false, "question": "Disposition for U-5: record_abort's 'moved' lede when the uuid is unchanged but the signature moved prints \"tail 'X' -> 'X'\", which reads as no movement — truthful but confusing.", "options": [ "fix-now", "defer-to-issue", "accept" ], "recommended": "accept", "finding_ref": "F-PO-46-8-5", "reasoning": "Cosmetic record style; the appended detail sentence carries the real cause. Not worth a fix round entry." } ], "suite": { "source": "git", "sha": "2ceacfe8490eb7efb2258c1d62981eea06acb97b", "dirty": false } } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "Exactly the tradeoff T-1's fix documented in SKILL.md and in the code comment (write access to the transcript is the presence the gate detects); the realistic trigger is an accidental paste-quote, which the next plain record corrects. Optional future hardening (conjoin the recorded promptSource/entrypoint discriminators with the marker test) is noted on the record; not required. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — the tradeoff is deliberate, documented in SKILL.md and the code comment; the promptSource hardening idea is recorded here for a future amendment if paste-quotes ever bite in practice."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "Exactly the tradeoff T-1's fix documented in SKILL.md and in the code comment (write access to the transcript is the presence the gate detects); the realistic trigger is an accidental paste-quote, which the next plain record corrects. Optional future hardening (conjoin the recorded promptSource/entrypoint discriminators with the marker test) is noted on the record; not required. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — the tradeoff is deliberate, documented in SKILL.md and the code comment; the promptSource hardening idea is recorded here for a future amendment if paste-quotes ever bite in practice." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "fix-now",
  "rationale": "Same class as T-4, same file, trivial: run every state number the script does arithmetic on through the same leading-zero-aware sanitize, and give a corrupt attempt the same honest treatment as a corrupt bound. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — same class as T-4, same file, trivial."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "fix-now", "rationale": "Same class as T-4, same file, trivial: run every state number the script does arithmetic on through the same leading-zero-aware sanitize, and give a corrupt attempt the same honest treatment as a corrupt bound. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "defer-to-issue: rejected — same class as T-4, same file, trivial." } ```

jbr870 commented

Author

Owner

{
  "status": "resolved",
  "chosen_option": "accept",
  "rationale": "Pre-existing default untouched by the rounds; attach always writes the field, so the path requires a hand-built state document. The honest-UNKNOWN pattern from T-4 could cover absence too, but absence-vs-corruption semantics on a machine-written file are #255's incident-lifecycle territory; not worth its own round here. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.",
  "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — reachable only on hand-built state; absence-vs-corruption semantics for machine-written state belong with #255's incident-lifecycle design."
}

```json { "status": "resolved", "chosen_option": "accept", "rationale": "Pre-existing default untouched by the rounds; attach always writes the field, so the path requires a hand-built state document. The honest-UNKNOWN pattern from T-4 could cover absence too, but absence-vs-corruption semantics on a machine-written file are #255's incident-lifecycle territory; not worth its own round here. — Resolved autonomously by the QA round driver under the operator's 'run QA for #46' delegation; choice matches the canonical recommender over the finding's recorded axes.", "rejected_alternative": "fix-now: rejected — reachable only on hand-built state; absence-vs-corruption semantics for machine-written state belong with #255's incident-lifecycle design." } ```

jbr870 commented